In the world of fantasy baseball, the heyday of first base is a distant memory. Once teeming with elite sluggers, the current pool of first basemen for the upcoming 2024 season is disappointingly unremarkable. With just two players, Matt Olson and Pete Alonso, among the 15 who hit at least 35 home runs last season, and only Freddie Freeman retaining 1B eligibility among the 64 players who stole more than 15 bases, the scarcity of impactful options at the position is evident.

This dearth of talent at first base has shifted the strategy for fantasy managers, as the recent rise in stolen bases throughout baseball encourages targeting players who can contribute in that category. As a result, the few remaining impactful first basemen become even more appealing and coveted in the early rounds of drafts. However, with only a handful of teams having the opportunity to acquire an elite first baseman, most managers will have to carefully navigate a large group of serviceable players in hopes of finding a breakout performer.

Fortunately, there are a few options that managers can target in their quest for a reliable first baseman. Christian Encarnacion-Strand, after meeting expectations in his rookie year with the Reds, shows promise with his power and high batting average potential. Despite facing competition in a crowded Reds infield, managers should take a chance on him, hoping that he secures a regular playing role.

Rhys Hoskins, a forgotten name in fantasy circles following his absence in the 2023 season due to injury, has joined the Brewers on a two-year deal. With an everyday role in a homer-friendly venue, Hoskins, known for his ability to hit the long ball, has the potential to hit 30 home runs in his first year in Milwaukee.

For those seeking a late-round power option, Kyle Manzardo, now Cleveland's primary first baseman, could provide a boom-or-bust choice. With an impressive power display in the minor leagues, he has already caught the attention of fantasy managers. However, his batting average remains unpredictable, making him a high-risk, high-reward selection.

In terms of the top-tier options, Freddie Freeman stands alone as a first-round choice. The Los Angeles Dodgers' veteran consistently ranks among the league leaders in batting average, runs, RBIs, and also adds stolen bases to his repertoire.

Matt Olson, now with the Atlanta Braves, topped the league in both home runs and RBIs last season while ranking third in runs scored. However, his lack of speed and batting average volatility push him down to the second round in drafts.

Pete Alonso, a more consistent slugger, may be a preferred choice for those wanting reliability. The New York Mets' formidable power hitter has been a home run leader since his debut in 2019 and continues to impress in that department. However, like Olson, his batting average can be a concern.

Bryce Harper, transitioning to first base for the Philadelphia Phillies, offers a unique combination of hitting ability, power, and stolen bases. If he can maintain his health and deliver a .300 average with 30 homers, he becomes a valuable asset.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr., once touted as one of the most promising prospects, had a standout season in 2021 but saw a dip in performance thereafter. This inconsistency leaves managers wondering about the young player's potential.

Lastly, Cody Bellinger, currently a free agent, breathed new life into his career with the Cubs, showcasing his speed and power. However, his past three seasons have been underwhelming, marring his position on the list.

Paul Goldschmidt, a longtime top-tier first baseman, experienced a slight decline last year but remains a solid choice for fantasy lineups.

As the 2024 fantasy baseball season approaches, managers must carefully navigate the scarcity of elite first basemen, considering each player's strengths and weaknesses. The draft will prove to be a crucial battleground in securing a valuable contributor at this position.