Ukrainian General's Admission Fuels Debate on Military Aid as War with Russia Stalls

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/15856210/original/open-uri20231102-57-nosq37?1698959363
ICARO Media Group
Politics
02/11/2023 21h07

In a striking admission, General Valery Zaluzhnyy, the commander in chief of Ukraine's armed forces, has declared that the war with Russia has reached a stalemate. His assessment has ignited a heated debate in Congress over whether to provide more weapons and support to Ukraine. The comments by Gen. Zaluzhnyy are resonating on Capitol Hill, particularly among Republicans who argue that it is time to reassess America's unwavering support for Kyiv.

Speaking to The Economist, Gen. Zaluzhnyy stated that without a significant boost in technological superiority, it is unlikely that there will be a breakthrough against Russia. He took responsibility for believing that Russian President Vladimir Putin would change course after suffering around 150,000 casualties. "In any other country such casualties would have stopped the war," he lamented.

Sen. Josh Hawley, a Republican from Missouri and a skeptic of increasing aid to Ukraine, seized on Gen. Zaluzhnyy's candid assessment, arguing that it significantly undermines the administration's Ukraine policy. According to Hawley, the current pitch is to continue funding Ukraine comprehensively, beyond just military support, while maintaining a stalemate.

However, Sen. Ben Cardin, a Democrat from Maryland and chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, believes that Gen. Zaluzhnyy's assessment aligns with the information they have been receiving. He expressed hope that Ukraine can at least hold onto what it has regained from Russia with the support of the United States. Since the counteroffensive began, Ukraine has only managed to advance approximately 10 miles.

The Senate is expected to approve additional aid to Ukraine as part of President Joe Biden's $106 billion request, which also includes support for Israel, Taiwan, and additional resources for the southern border with Mexico.

On the other hand, House Speaker Mike Johnson faces the task of convincing more skeptical colleagues. While Johnson expressed support for providing more weapons to Ukraine, he believes that lawmakers will only approve such deliveries separately from an Israel-focused measure.

Gen. Zaluzhnyy's remarks appear to be strategically aimed at influencing the ongoing congressional debate. He, along with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, is desperate for more advanced fighter jets, drones, longer-range missiles, and artillery that could potentially break through Russian lines.

Acknowledging the limitations of relying on donations, Ukraine is exploring partnerships with U.S. and European defense industries to establish co-production agreements, allowing them to build their own weapons. BAE Systems and Germany's Rheinmetall AG have already signed such deals, although production has yet to commence.

Sen. J.D. Vance, a Republican from Ohio, who has been vocal about ending military assistance to Ukraine, claims that Gen. Zaluzhnyy's remarks reveal deep divisions within Ukraine's leadership. Vance predicts that the conflict will ultimately result in Russia controlling some Ukrainian territory and a negotiated settlement. He argues that these realities on the ground have been evident for some time.

While Vance and Hawley's perspective represents a minority view in the Senate, with most senators from both parties supporting continued assistance to Ukraine, their arguments are gaining traction as attention shifts towards Israel's conflict with Hamas.

Nevertheless, Gen. Zaluzhnyy's comments have not weakened the support of Congress' most vocal advocates for Ukraine. Sen. Richard Blumenthal, a Democrat from Connecticut and member of the Senate Armed Services Committee, emphasized the significance of supporting Ukraine for national security reasons, even if a decisive breakthrough is unlikely. He acknowledges that progress will likely be slow, mile-by-mile.

As the debate over military aid to Ukraine intensifies, lawmakers in Congress face the challenge of balancing Ukraine's urgent need for assistance with the geopolitical complexities and constraints on achieving a significant breakthrough in the war with Russia.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related