Underachieving Steelers' Trade for Mike Williams at NFL Trade Deadline

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/16391681/original/open-uri20241106-17-p6wnj9?1730923901
ICARO Media Group
News
06/11/2024 20h06

### Steelers' Trade for Mike Williams Falls Short of Expectations

The Pittsburgh Steelers' recent acquisition of wide receiver Mike Williams from the New York Jets at the NFL trade deadline has raised eyebrows and drawn mixed reactions. Despite the move indicating a show of faith within the team's locker room, its impact may be more superficial than transformative, particularly when scrutinized against the backdrop of other recent NFL trades.

Standing tall at 6-foot-4, Mike Williams gives the Steelers an impressive array of big targets, joining the ranks of George Pickens (6-3), Pat Freiermuth (6-5), and Darnell Washington (6-7). However, the 30-year-old's performance in recent years tempers enthusiasm. Once the seventh overall pick in the 2017 draft, Williams had his last 1,000-yard season in 2021. A torn ACL during the 2023 season’s third game further curtailed his productivity.

Williams' acquisition is predictable yet underwhelming. With six wideouts traded since the season started, Williams ranks as the fifth-best among them. Notably, the Steelers needed a receiver of the caliber of DeAndre Hopkins, who recently scored two touchdowns in just his second game for the Kansas City Chiefs. That the Chiefs snagged Hopkins for a mere conditional fifth-round pick leaves many questioning the Steelers' strategy.

Replacing Diontae Johnson, who was sent to the Carolina Panthers in March and subsequently traded to the Baltimore Ravens, took until Tuesday, spotlighting the team's slow response. Williams, despite his physicality and ability to make combat catches, does not offer the same potential to become a No. 1 receiver, particularly in the event of an injury to George Pickens.

Adding to the uncertainty, there are doubts about how quickly Williams can adapt to the Steelers' playbook, given his past issues with running correct routes—a problem pointed out by Jets quarterback Aaron Rodgers, albeit contentiously.

In contrast, quarterback Russell Wilson, known for his efficiency in the red zone and his trademark moon balls, might benefit from Williams' towering presence, particularly inside the 10-yard line. Yet, this potential advantage does little to assuage concerns about the overall upgrade Williams represents.

While Williams could serve as a mentor to the younger receivers on the team, his past performance flaws cast a shadow on the likelihood of him being a significant influence. Ultimately, while Williams adds another big target for Wilson, he does not elevate the Steelers' chances in a meaningful way, especially compared to what a player like DeAndre Hopkins might have contributed.

The acquisition of Mike Williams, while not without its merits, appears to be a minor upgrade. The Steelers might have been better served by making a more decisive move to bolster their roster ahead of the crucial playoff stretch.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related