Saints' Controversial Decision to Attempt Onside Kick Proves Costly in Loss to Rams

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/15953211/original/open-uri20231222-18-8soun6?1703280398
ICARO Media Group
Politics
22/12/2023 21h25

In a surprising turn of events, the New Orleans Saints made a questionable decision to attempt an onside kick during their game against the Los Angeles Rams, ultimately leading to a costly defeat. Despite their valiant efforts to narrow a 23-point deficit to just eight points late in the game, the Saints' onside kick failed, giving the Rams favorable field position and effectively sealing their victory.

The Saints' head coach, Dennis Allen, acknowledged that the team had been struggling to stop the Rams' offense, but many critics argue that opting for an onside kick was not the wisest choice. While Allen's concern about their defensive performance is valid, the risk of recovering an onside kick is incredibly low, while the consequences of giving the Rams the ball at the Saints' 45-yard line were much more severe.

Interestingly, just moments earlier, the Saints had successfully blocked a punt, amplifying the pressure on the Rams. The fear of encountering a second blocked punt could have influenced the Rams' playcalling, potentially leading to more aggressive, and potentially flawed, decisions. Incomplete passes could have stopped the clock and given the Saints an opportunity to regain possession.

Had the Saints decided to kick the ball away, the psychological dynamic of the drive might have significantly shifted. Starting from their own 25-yard line, the Rams would not have felt as confident in their ability to secure the win, and the Saints would have had a better chance at turning the game back in their favor.

Nevertheless, even if the Saints had chosen to kick away, the outcome of the game might not have changed. The Rams had already demonstrated their offensive prowess, and the Saints would have faced an uphill battle in attempting to force a punt. However, the difference in field position, a significant thirty yards, would have undoubtedly impacted the game's trajectory.

The decision to rely on an onside kick, an extremely low-percentage play, as a hail mary attempt was a risky move that ultimately proved to be the wrong one for the Saints. Pinning their hopes on an outcome that rarely materializes was a questionable strategy, particularly when circumstances favored a more conservative approach.

In the grand scheme of things, the Saints' loss can be attributed to a series of factors rather than solely resting on the onside kick attempt. However, it serves as a reminder of the importance of calculated decision-making and the potential consequences that can arise from high-risk plays.

As the league continues to analyze the game, it remains to be seen whether the Saints' controversial choice will steer future teams away from similar endeavors. The onside kick strategy, while occasionally successful, often proves to be a gamble that may not be worth the reward in critical moments like this.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related