Russell Wilson vs. Justin Fields: A Close Comparison for the 2024 NFL Season
ICARO Media Group
In the ongoing debate of which quarterback would be the better choice for the 2024 season, Russell Wilson and Justin Fields have emerged as the front-runners. The decision, however, is not an easy one, as both quarterbacks bring different strengths and considerations to the table.
One factor to consider is the financial aspect. Wilson, with his vast experience and impressive track record, could potentially be acquired at a veteran's minimum salary, given the Broncos' current situation of paying him $39 million not to play for them in 2024. On the other hand, Fields, entering the final year of his rookie contract, has a cap hit of just over $6 million. The question arises concerning Fields' fifth-year option, which, if picked up, would see him earn around $25 million in 2025. A strong 2024 season could significantly increase his market value, with franchise quarterbacks typically earning a minimum of $40 million.
Trade capital is also a factor to consider. Since Fields is still under contract, acquiring him would likely require at least one high draft pick, possibly a second-round pick, or multiple mid-round picks. Wilson, with an extensive career spanning 204 starts and 105 more wins than Fields, offers a wealth of experience and knowledge that could prove invaluable to a team.
When it comes to on-field performance, Wilson's game has evolved over the years. While his mobility has diminished, he remains agile in the pocket and maintains accuracy in his throws. However, concerns arise regarding the number of times Wilson has been sacked, with a league-high 55 sacks in 2022 and a total of 45 sacks in 15 games last season. The toll of these hits could affect his long-term performance.
Fields, at 24 years old, possesses a more youthful and mobile style of play. His ability to extend plays and make big plays with his legs sets him apart. While accuracy remains a concern, with a career-high completion percentage of 61.4%, Fields' leadership and durability make him an enticing choice.
Leadership styles also come into play. Wilson's leadership has faced scrutiny in both Seattle and Denver, with opinions varying on whether his style is a good fit for every team. Fields, meanwhile, has shown a more quiet yet impactful leadership style, exemplified by his captaincy during his time in Chicago.
Ultimately, the decision between Wilson and Fields comes down to personal preference and team needs. For this writer, Fields is the preferred choice for his mobility, durability, and potential to make big plays. Both quarterbacks, however, will undoubtedly be closely watched as they strive to lead their teams to success in the upcoming 2024 NFL season.
With the 2024 season yet to unfold, football enthusiasts eagerly await the performances of these talented quarterbacks, eager to see who will ultimately excel on the field.
Sources: CBS Sports, NFL experts