Texas Legislator Vows to Ban Use of Unclaimed Bodies for Research Following Scandal

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/16359300/original/open-uri20240928-17-hg7rgx?1727481755
ICARO Media Group
Politics
27/09/2024 23h59

****

In response to a recent NBC News investigation, a Texas state legislator is pledging to end the use of unclaimed bodies for medical research. The investigative report revealed that a local medical program had studied hundreds of human specimens without obtaining permission from their families. Republican Sen. Tan Parker, who represents parts of Dallas and Tarrant counties, plans to introduce a bill in the forthcoming January legislative session to prohibit the use of unclaimed bodies unless explicit consent is given by the deceased or their families.

Sen. Parker, who has previously attempted to regulate the body brokerage industry, was taken aback by the findings that the University of North Texas Health Science Center in Fort Worth dissected and leased parts of unclaimed bodies to for-profit companies and institutions, including the Army. Some of these bodies belonged to individuals whose families were actively searching for them. "I was outraged and completely disgusted to see what had been occurring," said Parker, emphasizing that while he supports the advancement of medicine through the study of human bodies, such practices must always have the consent of the deceased or their families. "Human life is sacred and needs to always be protected, and that is a core principle to me."

The Health Science Center has not commented on Parker's proposed legislation. However, in a statement, university spokesperson Andy North admitted that the center "fell short of the standards of respect, care, and professionalism that we demand." Historically, unclaimed bodies have often been used for medical training and research, but shifts in medical ethics have led many states and body-donation programs to end this practice.

Local officials in North Texas had justified using unclaimed bodies for research by citing cost savings for local governments and the benefits to medical training and research. NBC News, however, discovered repeated failures by death investigators and the Health Science Center to contact reachable relatives before deeming bodies unclaimed. This has led to immediate changes and public outcry. The Health Science Center suspended its body-donation program, terminated the officials in charge, and stated it would cease accepting unclaimed bodies. Medical and research organizations involved are also reconsidering their use of unclaimed bodies and reviewing their internal policies.

Tarrant County Commissioner Alisa Simmons stated she would advocate for new policies to ensure the humane treatment of unclaimed deceased individuals. Dallas County officials have also committed to only providing unclaimed bodies for research if survivors explicitly approve. Nevertheless, for many affected families, like that of Victor Honey, a 58-year-old homeless Army veteran whose body was used without consent, the damage has already been done. Brenda Cloud, Victor Honey’s sister, expressed her anger and hopes that new laws prevent such situations in the future.

The scandal has drawn the attention of other prominent figures. The Rev. Al Sharpton has labeled the issue as a civil rights concern that warrants government intervention, arguing it strips families of their rights and their loved ones' dignity. Medical experts, including Thomas Champney of the University of Miami, have called for federal legislation to prevent such practices nationwide, and bioethicist Eli Shupe sees Texas' potential legislative action as a model for other states.

Families affected, like Louisa Harvey, whose fiancé Michael Coleman’s body was used by the center while he was missing, have found some solace in the recent assurances but remain emotionally distressed. Harvey, still uncertain about whether the ashes she received are truly Coleman's, criticized the Health Science Center’s apology, describing it as merely a reaction to getting caught. University spokesperson Andy North stated that officials are making efforts to reach out to affected families to express their apologies.

This series of events has spurred hopes of sweeping changes, with affected families and officials alike aiming to ensure that no other family endures similar trauma.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related