Payment Mishap Delays Platform X's Reinstatement in Brazil

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/16365246/original/open-uri20241005-18-1mhu6k0?1728163108
ICARO Media Group
Politics
05/10/2024 21h02

### X's Battle with Brazilian Supreme Court: Payment Mishap Keeps Platform Suspended

In an effort to resume operations in Brazil, social media platform X, formerly known as Twitter, attempted to pay fines owed to the Brazilian government. However, a new obstacle has emerged as the Supreme Court reported that the fines were deposited into the wrong bank account. Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes clarified that the payment of 28.6 million reais ($5.24 million) did not reach the correct account associated with the proceedings.

The payment mishap is the latest development in an ongoing dispute between X's owner, Elon Musk, and the Brazilian authorities. Earlier in the day, X submitted a formal request to reinstate its services in Brazil, asserting that the fines had been paid. "X Brasil requests that the platform be unblocked for free access by its users in national territory," read the company's document seeking the lifting of the suspension.

Brazil suspended X in August due to the platform's failure to comply with court orders on content moderation and the appointment of a legal representative within the country. This has ignited a broader debate on free speech and the measures required to combat misinformation online. The suspension affects one of X's biggest markets, with more than 21 million users in Brazil, according to data firm Statista.

The fines, which exceed $5 million, were imposed after X failed to moderate accounts linked to misinformation and figures accused of undermining Brazil's elections. Additionally, the court demanded the appointment of a local legal representative, a requirement X initially failed to meet. Musk, who openly criticized the suspension, called the orders "illegal" and referred to Justice de Moraes as an "evil dictator cosplaying as a judge."

Despite Musk's initial resistance, X appears to be softening its stance toward Brazilian regulations. In September, the platform restricted access to accounts spreading misinformation and initiated steps to appoint legal representatives in Brazil. These actions were part of X’s plea to restore user access.

Since Musk's acquisition, X has shown a trend of complying with governmental requests for content removal, accommodating nearly 99 percent of such demands from countries like Turkey and India in early 2023. This has raised concerns about potential governmental overreach and the silencing of critics on the platform.

In its recent overtures to the Brazilian government, X's moves suggest a willingness to adapt to the country's regulatory framework. Whether these efforts will finally lead to the lifting of the suspension remains to be seen. For now, the platform must address the payment error and continue working toward meeting Brazil's legal requirements.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related