Trump Administration Shifts Stance on Crypto in Retirement Plans
ICARO Media Group
****
In a notable policy change, regulators under the Trump administration have removed warnings about cryptocurrencies from retirement plans, standing apart from the more cautionary approach taken by the Biden administration. Previously, in 2022, the Biden administration had advised extreme care in incorporating digital assets like Bitcoin into 401(k) plans, suggesting such investments can be challenging to evaluate, even for seasoned investors. However, the Trump administration reversed this guidance on May 28, opting for a neutral stance that neither encourages nor dissuades the inclusion of cryptocurrencies in retirement plans.
Lori Chavez-DeRemer, the labor secretary, criticized the Biden-era's interventionist approach, asserting that investment decisions should be left to fiduciaries, not bureaucrats in Washington. Notably, this move aligns with the Trump administration's broader enthusiasm for the crypto industry, despite ethical concerns related to President Trump and his family's involvement in the sector.
Despite this reversal, a significant shift towards including cryptocurrencies in the more than 715,000 401(k) plans, which hold approximately $8.9 trillion in assets, is not anticipated. Experts cite concerns about the volatile nature of digital assets and legal repercussions as reasons for this reluctance. Many plan administrators remain cautious, fearing lawsuits over far less controversial investments than crypto.
Bryan Armour from Morningstar highlighted that, while some marketers tout crypto as a diversifier and safe haven, it has often failed to meet these expectations. Nonetheless, crypto investments have proven lucrative for those who weather market downturns. Fidelity, a significant player in the 401(k) market, has facilitated crypto investments through a digital asset account since 2022, allowing participants to allocate part of their retirement funds to Bitcoin.
Ali Khawar, a former Labor Department official under the Biden administration, emphasized that fiduciaries must still carefully consider the suitability of digital assets. Without government guidance, plan managers face increased responsibility to discern the appropriateness of these investments, with the potential for legal consequences if they falter.
Meanwhile, the rising availability of exchange-traded products (ETFs) that include cryptocurrency holdings makes it simpler for investors to access digital coins. Notably, established firms like BlackRock and Fidelity introduced Bitcoin ETFs, amassing $126 billion in assets since January 2024 and achieving a 123 percent return. Ethereum ETFs followed but attracted less investment.
However, despite these developments, only a minority of workplace plans offer a brokerage window, which would allow participants broader investment choices, including crypto ETFs. As per the Governmental Accountability Office's study, nearly 70 crypto-related investment options are potentially available within 401(k) plans, though more than 70 new crypto funds are still awaiting approval from the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Ultimately, while the Trump administration's policy shift might facilitate procedural access to cryptocurrencies in retirement plans, financial experts stress that it does not lower the standard for fiduciaries responsible for prudent investment choices. For most plan administrators, the door to crypto investments in 401(k) plans remains cautiously closed.