Vigilante Shooter Released on Bail, Returns Home Clad in Arrested Attire

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/15873068/original/open-uri20231110-56-ocshru?1699646095
ICARO Media Group
Politics
10/11/2023 19h53

In a surprising turn of events, John Rote, the vigilante who opened fire at a Manhattan subway station this week while intervening in a potential mugging, has been released on bail. The 43-year-old was spotted returning to his Queens home on Friday morning, still wearing the very same clothes in which he was apprehended.

During his Thursday night arraignment, prosecutors requested that Rote be held on $10,000 bail, which was granted. Rote, however, declined to answer any questions both inside a shop and in front of his Astoria home, where he encountered difficulty gaining entry.

Witnesses observed Rote looking through paperwork before finally trudging off towards the nearby subway station at 31st Street and 30th Avenue. It seems that Rote's return home was anything but smooth.

Rote, who has no prior criminal record and has never been deemed in need of psychiatric assistance, now faces charges of criminal possession of a weapon, criminal possession of a firearm, reckless endangerment, and menacing. These charges are in connection to the incident in which Rote was caught on camera firing two shots at the 49th Street station in Midtown on Tuesday.

The chaotic situation unfolded when 49-year-old Matthew Roesch, a homeless man, held the emergency gate open for a 40-year-old woman at the Midtown station. Roesch allegedly demanded money from the woman, warning her that he would take her purse if she didn't comply. Refusing his demands, the woman became the target of Roesch's verbal abuse.

It was at this moment that Rote, apparently compelled to act, warned the panhandler to leave the woman alone. Witnesses reported that Rote then took out a gun and shouted, "Get away from her!"

Rich Davey, the chief of the MTA's subway and city bus systems, described the shooting as "unusual" during a Wednesday news conference. He noted that the shooter appeared calm, firing the shots before calmly placing the gun back in a bag and leaving the scene. Davey stressed the importance of preventing such incidents and stated unequivocally that this kind of behavior would not be tolerated in the New York City transit system.

Law enforcement sources have indicated that they do not believe Rote was targeting the vagrant with his shots. Rote was arrested at his workplace on Wednesday afternoon without incident. Authorities apprehended him at Panavision, a company that specializes in renting camera and filmmaking equipment located on Varick Street. Rote allegedly admitted to pulling the trigger and subsequently disposing of the gun in the East River.

At his arraignment, Rote's defense attorney, Marie Calvert-Kilbane, argued that her client legally purchased the gun approximately 13 years ago. She asserted that Rote was simply a "concerned" citizen who intervened to ensure the safety of a fellow subway passenger. Calvert-Kilbane emphasized that Rote did not obtain the weapon from illegal sources.

It has also been revealed that Rote had previously been arrested for selling MetroCard swipes, according to NYPD Inspector Steven Hill, the commanding officer of the Transit Borough Manhattan.

As the case unfolds, there is sure to be significant public debate about the appropriate boundaries of citizen intervention and the consequences of taking the law into one's own hands. The aftermath of Rote's actions will undoubtedly shed light on these complex issues, stirring discussions on crime prevention and public safety in the city.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related