Harvard-Affiliated Cancer Institute Investigates Allegations of Data Falsification by Top Researchers

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/16007222/original/open-uri20240122-56-ft8l5h?1705965152
ICARO Media Group
News
22/01/2024 23h10

In a recent development, the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, a Harvard University-affiliated teaching hospital, has initiated retractions and corrections to academic papers authored by four of its leading researchers. Following an investigation into allegations of data falsification, the hospital's research integrity officer, Dr. Barrett Rollins, confirmed that six retractions have already been initiated, with another 31 papers currently undergoing correction.

The researchers implicated in the probe include the cancer institute's CEO, Dr. Laurie Glimcher, chief operating officer Dr. William Hahn, director of the Clinical Investigator Research Program Dr. Irene Ghobrial, and Jerome Lipper Multiple Myeloma Center program director Dr. Kenneth Anderson. All four researchers hold faculty appointments with the prestigious Harvard Medical School.

The allegations came to light after a data sleuth, Sholto David, published a blog post raising concerns about irregularities in a total of 57 papers. It remains unclear whether the institute has found evidence of misconduct during its investigation.

Dr. Rollins emphasized that discrepancies identified in some of the papers do not necessarily prove an intent to deceive on the part of the authors. He explained that a careful examination is needed to establish whether there was any misconduct. Dr. Rollins further stated that errors are often unintentional and may not rise to the level of misconduct.

According to Dr. Rollins, prompt and decisive action has been taken in relation to the first 37 papers, while the investigation into the 38th manuscript is ongoing. Of the remaining 19 papers flagged by Sholto David, three require no further action, and the data under scrutiny in the remaining 16 papers were collected in laboratories unaffiliated with the four researchers implicated.

Dr. Rollins indicated that efforts are being made to contact the heads of these laboratories in order to rectify any necessary corrections to the literature. He reaffirmed the institute's commitment to a culture of accountability and integrity, ensuring that inquiries related to research integrity are thoroughly examined.

At the time of reporting, Dr. Glimcher and the other three researchers had not responded to requests for comment. The Post also reached out to the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute for their perspective on the matter.

These fresh allegations are the latest in a series of claims brought against Harvard-affiliated researchers, following the resignation of Harvard University president, Claudine Gay, amid a plagiarism controversy involving nearly 50 accusations. The Harvard Corporation, the university's governing board, conducted a review and found a few instances of inadequate citation but no evidence of research misconduct. The board stated that Gay would revise her dissertation and request corrections.

As the investigation proceeds, the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute remains focused on upholding accountability and integrity within its research practices.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related