In what is being described as one of the worst quarterback draft classes in recent memory, NFL teams are facing a daunting decision on how to secure their future at the crucial position. The 2024 draft class has been deemed as potentially rivaling the notoriously awful 2022 class, which included the underwhelming quartet of Kenny Pickett, Desmond Ridder, Malik Willis, and Matt Corral as the top four passers off the board.

With only Shedeur Sanders and Carson Beck making the cut on the 2025 big board of renowned draft expert J.P. Acosta, concerns have been raised about the remaining quarterbacks on the list. Many either face significant question marks or are simply deemed inadequate for the demanding role. Building a franchise around Sanders or Beck doesn't appear to be an enticing proposition for teams seeking to secure a solid future at the position.

However, while the top-tier talent of the 2024 draft class, including Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, and Drake Maye, could turn heads in any year, it is the second and third-tier quarterbacks who are expected to benefit the most from the lackluster 2025 class. This has led to a significant boost in draft stock for players like McCarthy, Penix, and Nix. McCarthy is predicted to climb into the top 10 picks, while Penix and Nix are considered at the very worst to be second-round selections, with the potential to even sneak into the back end of the first round.

The mediocrity of the 2025 class has caused some quarterbacks, such as Spencer Rattler and Jordan Travis, to potentially be drafted two-to-three rounds earlier than they would in a stronger draft year. The fear of missing out on a competent quarterback has put teams on high alert as they are unwilling to wait for the 2026 draft or rely on the dwindling veteran market for their needs.

This perfect storm of circumstances has generated immense hype around the 2025 QB class, despite it being not significantly better than previous years. A closer analysis of the post-combine scouting grades from NFL.com over the past three years reveals the recency bias that plagues the evaluation of this particular class.

In conclusion, NFL teams find themselves in a precarious situation as they navigate a weak 2025 quarterback draft class. The scarcity of viable options has led to inflated stock for some lesser-known prospects, while the pressure to secure a franchise-caliber signal-caller is higher than ever. Only time will tell how teams cope with this challenging situation and whether they are able to identify the diamonds in the rough amidst the underwhelming talent pool.