New York Jets quarterback Aaron Rodgers is facing skepticism over the extent of his Achilles tendon tear, according to Indianapolis Star columnist Gregg Doyel. Doyel, in a recent post on X, expressed doubts about the severity of Rodgers' injury, suggesting that the quarterback may not have suffered a typical torn Achilles.

Rodgers has been vocal about his intent to return to the field sooner than the average recovery timeline of around 12 months, thanks to an innovative surgery. An internal brace, commonly referred to as an Achilles "speed brace," was reportedly applied to his torn left Achilles, potentially enabling a speedier recovery, as reported by NFL Network sources.

Despite being just four plays into the season when he sustained the injury, Rodgers has been actively involved in Jets games, seen throwing footballs at MetLife Stadium and walking without the aid of crutches. He recently stated in an interview with NBC's Melissa Stark that he aims to make a comeback by mid-December.

Throughout his recovery, Rodgers has been updating fans on his progress through appearances on "The Pat McAfee Show." During his latest interview, he expressed a desire to resume practicing by his 40th birthday, which falls on December 2, and revealed that he has begun jogging on a treadmill. However, he clarified that he would only accelerate his return if the Jets, who currently hold a record of 4-6, remain in contention.

Responding to skeptics like Doyel and Billy Gil of "The Dan Le Batard Show with Stugotz," Rodgers defended the legitimacy of his injury, suggesting that those questioning his Achilles injury were more willing to entertain theories about his recovery than they were about concerns regarding COVID-19 vaccines and gene therapy.

The final decision on Rodgers' return, according to Jets coach Robert Saleh, rests with the quarterback himself once he receives clearance from medical professionals.