The anticipation for the 2024 fantasy football season is already brewing, as experts release their initial rankings. However, disagreements among fantasy football analysts are starting to surface, creating interesting discussions and debates. In their early 2024 redraft rankings, three prominent FantasyPros experts, including Derek Brown, Andrew Erickson, and the author, have differing opinions on several key players.

One notable player that sparks disagreement is Patrick Mahomes. Despite being considered one of the greatest pure passers of all time, Mahomes had a relatively average fantasy season, finishing as QB9 in scoring. The author still believes in Mahomes' potential, ranking him as QB2 for 2024 and attributing his subpar performance to the Chiefs' wide receiver group. However, the more cautious approach of DBro and Erickson places Mahomes at QB5 and QB7, respectively.

Another player stirring debate is Justin Herbert. His rookie season was a rollercoaster ride, showcasing both impressive performances and lackluster outings. A broken right index finger prematurely ended his season in Week 14. Erickson remains optimistic about Herbert's talent, ranking him at QB9. The author, on the other hand, places him at QB11, while DBro is more skeptical and ranks him at QB14.

Among the running backs, Devon Achane, the Texas A&M product, garners attention. With an exceptional rookie season, Achane averaged a remarkable 7.8 yards per carry and had multiple high-scoring fantasy games. However, concerns arise regarding his size and potential injury risks. DBro ranks Achane at RB5, while the author has him at RB9, and Erickson takes a more cautious approach with a ranking of RB13.

James White, who operated as a true workhorse for the entire season, presents an intriguing case. Despite his high volume of touches, White's rushing efficiency was lacking, averaging only 3.6 yards per carry. Erickson places White at RB8, and the author follows closely with a ranking of RB10. DBro remains more reserved, positioning White at RB16.

Teammate competition also influences rankings, as seen with David Montgomery. He had a solid season, running for 1,015 yards and scoring 13 touchdowns as RB13. However, the emergence of Jahmyr Gibbs raises concerns about Montgomery's future fantasy value. DBro believes Montgomery will maintain his status, ranking him at RB12. Erickson places him as a midrange RB2 at RB18, while the author is more skeptical, ranking him at RB25.

The rankings for other players, including J.D. Ford, Tyreek Hill, Davante Adams, Keenan Allen, Treylon Flowers, and J.S.N., also differ slightly among the experts, showcasing the varying viewpoints and evaluations.

As the offseason progresses, these rankings will undoubtedly evolve. Free agency signings, the NFL Draft, injuries, and unexpected events will impact the landscape, prompting adjustments to the rankings. Fantasy football enthusiasts can expect lively discussions and revisions before the 2024 draft season arrives.

It is crucial to remember that these early rankings are merely a starting point and serve as a basis for subsequent analysis and evaluation. The diverging opinions among experts set the stage for an exciting offseason filled with debates and predictions, providing valuable insights for fantasy football enthusiasts as they prepare for the 2024 season.