Kelly Carlin Criticizes Release of AI-Generated George Carlin Comedy Special
ICARO Media Group
American radio host and daughter of legendary comedian George Carlin, Kelly Carlin, has expressed her disdain over the recent release of a comedy special featuring an AI-generated version of her late father. Taking to Twitter, Carlin conveyed her disappointment and emphasized that no machine could ever replicate her father's genius.
The controversial comedy special, titled "I'm Glad I'm Dead," was released on the YouTube channel and podcast called Dudesy on Tuesday. The channel, known for utilizing AI technology, describes itself as a "first of its kind media experiment." The hour-long special began with a disclaimer, stating that it featured an impersonation of George Carlin developed by the AI host, Dudesy.
The AI-generated George Carlin addressed the audience, comparing the impersonation to Andy Kaufman's portrayal of Elvis or Will Ferrell's impersonation of George W. Bush. Throughout the special, various topics were explored, including religion, mass shootings, Donald Trump, billionaires, technology, and identity. A segment also focused on Elon Musk, with the AI impersonation suggesting ways to counter his influence.
Following the release of the special, Kelly Carlin voiced her disapproval, urging audiences to let her father's authentic work speak for itself. She questioned why people were afraid of leaving the void that exists after an artist's passing, suggesting that listeners support living human comedians instead. Carlin pointed out that her father's genuine comedy can be found in his extensive collection of 14 specials.
Kelly Carlin extended her call to the adult children of other late comedians, including Zelda Williams, daughter of Robin Williams, Melissa Rivers, daughter of Joan Rivers, and the official account of Garry Shandling, who passed away in 2016.
This is not the first time creators have come under fire for using AI to generate fake content. Last year, former NFL champion Tom Brady threatened legal action against Dudesy after they released an AI-generated comedy special featuring a fake Brady. The special was eventually taken down due to its alleged infringement on Brady's rights.
In 2021, a documentary about the late celebrity chef Anthony Bourdain received backlash for using AI to create a synthetic voiceover of Bourdain himself. The controversy prompted criticism from Bourdain's ex-wife and others involved in the documentary.
The release of the AI-generated George Carlin comedy special has sparked a debate about the ethics of using AI technology to recreate the voices and personas of deceased individuals. While some argue that it allows fans to enjoy new content from their favorite artists, others firmly believe that it cheapens the legacy and authenticity of the original artists.
As the conversation surrounding AI-generated content continues, the legacy and impact of artists like George Carlin remain at the forefront, reminding us of the irreplaceable nature of their talent and unique perspectives.