In an unexpected move during the first week of free agency, the Pittsburgh Steelers were able to secure both Russell Wilson and Justin Fields for their quarterback room. However, according to CBS Sports data scientist Stephen Oh, Fields actually gives the Steelers a better chance of winning in 2024.

Oh's analysis reveals that with Wilson as the starting quarterback, the Steelers' playoff chances stand at 25.6%, while that number jumps to 35.9% with Fields under center. While Oh believes that Fields is the answer, let's delve into various categories to determine who should start for the Steelers in 2024.

When it comes to experience, Wilson clearly has the edge. With 204 career starts, he outshines Fields, who has started in only a handful of NFL games. Wilson's 124 wins, coupled with his valuable playoff experience, provide a veteran perspective that can prove invaluable for the team.

However, concerns arise over Wilson's durability. He has endured a significant number of hits and sacks over his career, leading to worries about potential wear and tear. In contrast, Fields, at 25 years old, has less mileage on his body and is considered more durable.

Wilson's accuracy and ability to take care of the ball remain strong. His deep-ball accuracy has not wavered, and he still possesses a strong arm. However, Fields, despite a slightly lower completion percentage, has the advantage of mobility and the ability to make big plays with his legs.

Leadership has also been a topic of discussion surrounding Wilson, with some questioning his style. However, early signs indicate a positive fit with the Steelers, as he has been warmly welcomed by key players on the team.

Considering the overall fit within the Steelers' current offensive roster, Wilson comes out ahead. While Fields has shown promise, the continuity and talent present in the 49ers' offense do not yet exist in Pittsburgh. Additionally, Wilson's experience in adapting to different offensive systems and teammates makes him better equipped to handle the transition.

Furthermore, Wilson brings the invaluable experience of winning games and his desire to return to the Super Bowl. The Steelers, hungry for another championship, see Wilson as the offensive leader who can guide them to success on the grandest stage.

In conclusion, Russell Wilson has been named the starting quarterback for the Pittsburgh Steelers in the upcoming 2024 season. While the decision is a close one, Wilson's experience, leadership, and ability to adjust to a new environment have given him the edge over Fields. Time will tell if Wilson's performance and Fields' adaptation can maintain this starting position throughout the season.