Western Support for Ukraine's Military Training Gains Momentum Amid Risks of Escalation
ICARO Media Group
In a significant departure from NATO countries' reluctance to deploy troops to Ukraine, Western armies have signaled their willingness to provide military trainers to Kyiv, according to General Charles Q. Brown Jr., the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Although the deployment of boots on the ground is not imminent, the growing number of European countries considering sending military personnel in supporting or training roles demonstrates an increasing commitment to assisting Ukraine in its defense efforts.
Gen. Brown emphasized the need for a cautious approach, stating that deploying NATO trainers now would put them at risk and divert air defenses that could be better utilized protecting Ukrainian soldiers on the battlefield. Despite this cautious stance, France's President Emmanuel Macron stated that "nothing should be ruled out," while officials from Estonia and Lithuania revealed their serious consideration of sending troops in non-combat roles, adding that training missions in Ukraine were feasible.
However, some NATO countries remain skeptical about the logistics and politics involved in training Ukrainian soldiers inside the country. Admiral Tony Radakin, the United Kingdom's top military official, expressed concerns about training outside Ukraine enduringly due to these challenges.
The potential deployment of Western boots on the ground in Ukraine could help Kyiv address its manpower deficit and enhance its training capabilities. However, it also poses risks for NATO, as any conflict escalation sparked by Russia could provoke direct confrontation between the United States and Russia, potentially straining the defense agreements within the NATO-EU coalition.
The Ukrainian soldiers have voiced concerns about the adequacy of Western training they have received so far. They contend that the focus on counterinsurgency falls short of preparing them for drone combat and trench warfare. Western officials, on the other hand, claim that their training programs have evolved to better meet Ukraine's needs, with adjustments made based on feedback from Ukrainian soldiers. Suggestions have been made for trainers to visit Ukraine or for Ukrainian troops to train Western instructors to better prepare their own soldiers.
In parallel to the potential Western support, Ukraine will implement a new mobilization law from May 18, 2023, aimed at summoning more people to bolster its military forces. The law anticipates that it will take several months before a larger army emerges due to the mobilization and training processes. However, having the capacity to train new recruits within Ukraine is deemed crucial by defense experts.
Meanwhile, Russia has launched a new offensive in Kharkiv, attempting to stretch Ukraine's forces thin with the aim of achieving a breakthrough advantage. Due to the limited number of troops, Ukraine has been compelled to deploy its best soldiers to areas with active fighting, leaving them with little time to recuperate.
As Western nations show increased willingness to provide military trainers, the risks of escalation and strain on NATO-EU relationships become prominent concerns. Ukraine's mobilization reform aims to boost troop numbers and enhance its defense capabilities in the long run. However, achieving a balance between supplying adequate training to Ukrainian soldiers and mitigating potential risks remains a significant challenge in this ongoing conflict.