Her conviction for the 2007 death of her 2-year-old daughter has been called into question following new findings that prosecutors withheld evidence suggesting the death was accidental.

Cameron County Judge Arturo Nelson delivered a significant ruling, declaring Lucio innocent of the charges and recommending that her death sentence be overturned. This decision was made public in a recent court filing, offering a ray of hope to Lucio and her supporters who have long argued that she was wrongfully convicted.

The ultimate decision now rests with the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. This court has the authority to either uphold or overturn Lucio’s conviction and sentence. If the court agrees with Judge Nelson's findings, Lucio could be set free after years of fighting to prove her innocence.

The case has drawn considerable attention as it underscores critical issues in the criminal justice system regarding due process and the withholding of exculpatory evidence. Advocates for Lucio argue that her case exemplifies the potential for miscarriages of justice when crucial evidence is not disclosed during the trial process.

Should the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals act in line with Judge Nelson's recommendation, it would mark a profound vindication for Lucio, concluding her lengthy legal battle and overturning a death sentence imposed over a decade ago.