Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has filed a lawsuit against the Biden administration regarding the federal contraception program that allows teens to access birth control without requiring parental consent. The Title X program has been the sole avenue for confidential contraception for minors in Texas until a recent court ruling mandated parental sign-off.

The Title X program, established during the Nixon era, ensures that anyone, regardless of income, immigration status, or age, can access confidential contraception. According to federal regulations and court rulings, Title X providers are prohibited from requiring teens to obtain parental permission for receiving birth control.

The legal battle began in 2020 when an Amarillo father, Alexander Deanda, sued over the provision, claiming that it violated his parental rights guaranteed by the Texas Constitution. The case was presented in federal court in Amarillo, where Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk, known for his conservative views, presides over most cases. Judge Kacsmaryk ruled in favor of Deanda, requiring Title X providers in Texas to obtain parental consent before prescribing birth control. The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld this decision in March.

However, in 2021, the Biden administration issued a new rule stating that Title X providers cannot require parental consent for minors seeking contraception services. The administration emphasized the importance of confidentiality in these cases. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton argues that the Biden administration's rule contradicts the 5th Circuit's judgment and is seeking a permanent injunction against it through the lawsuit.

Paxton's lawsuit has been filed in federal court in Amarillo, where it is likely to be heard by Judge Kacsmaryk, who previously ruled against the program's confidentiality clause. Paxton denounced the Biden administration's actions, stating that it undermines the Constitution and violates the law.

Title X providers, such as Every Body Texas, the statewide program administrator, have not yet responded to the lawsuit. In the past, these providers have emphasized the importance of confidentiality in their work with minors, as some young individuals may not have a safe environment to ask their parents for permission to access birth control.

The lawsuit does not change the current situation in Texas, since Title X providers are already requiring parental consent. However, it is part of a larger trend in the state to restrict access to reproductive health care. Texas has seen a rise in teen pregnancy rates after implementing strict abortion laws, and with further limitations on contraception, healthcare providers and advocates express concern over even higher numbers in the future.

Dr. Luis Garza, chief medical officer of Title X provider Project Vida in El Paso, reported a 50% drop in appointments for contraception by teenagers after requiring parental consent. Many teens are reluctant to seek help due to fear of their parents finding out, leading to missed opportunities for reproductive health care.

The Texas Tribune Festival, scheduled for September 5-7 in downtown Austin, will feature notable figures such as director Richard Linklater, NPR President Katherine Maher, U.S. Rep. Pete Aguilar, and Luci Baines Johnson. The festival aims to address important issues and provide a platform for dialogue and discussion.

Support for independent Texas reporting is crucial to ensure fact-based journalism for Texans. The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit newsroom, relies on donations from readers and supporters to deliver in-depth news and information. Contributions from the community help bring truth to the forefront and serve millions with reliable journalism.