Montana Senate Race Moves to Leans Republican, Indicating GOP Favor for Senate Control

ICARO Media Group
Politics
06/09/2024 18h44

In a significant shift, the Crystal Ball has updated its rating for the crucial Senate election in Montana, moving it from a Toss-up to Leans Republican. This change solidifies the Republicans' position as clear favorites to flip control of the Senate in the upcoming November elections, with a majority of Senate seats now leaning towards the GOP.

The decision to adjust the rating comes after careful consideration and analysis. Although the Crystal Ball initially hesitated to change the rating, recent polling data and input from both sides of the political spectrum have indicated that businessman Tim Sheehy (R) is likely leading in the race against incumbent Senator Jon Tester (D-MT).

While Montana is not frequently polled due to its status as a non-presidential swing state, recent polls have consistently shown Sheehy with a modest lead over Tester. A recent AARP-commissioned bipartisan poll revealed a 51% to 45% lead for Sheehy in a two-person race, and a 49% to 41% lead when Libertarian and Green candidates were included.

Critics may argue that the rating change is based on a single poll, but the Crystal Ball emphasizes that the AARP poll served as the final piece of information needed to make an informed decision. Other polls conducted in recent months also showed Sheehy in the lead, with the Emerson College poll showing a 2-point lead for Sheehy.

In addition to the polling, historical trends and demographics in Montana have not been favorable for Senator Tester. Holding a Senate seat that was won by the opposing party by a significant margin in the last presidential election, Tester faces an uphill battle against the backdrop of a shifting political landscape.

Despite the rating change, it is important to note that Leans Republican does not guarantee victory for Sheehy. Montana remains a challenging state to poll, and both parties are heavily invested in the outcome of this race. Polling inaccuracies, as seen in past elections, cannot be ruled out.

Looking ahead, the Crystal Ball currently identifies only one Senate race, Ohio, as a Toss-up. Democrats will need to maintain or flip currently Republican-held seats in order to have a chance at winning the Senate majority, should Tester lose. The party is eyeing Senate races in states like Texas and Florida as potential opportunities.

As the election draws closer, the Crystal Ball expects the level of uncertainty in some of these races to increase. However, given the significant exposure for Democrats this year, the projection remains that Republicans are likely to gain control of the Senate.

It's worth noting that incumbent senators who have polled below 50% in the summer or just before the election have not been doomed to defeat. Democratic performance in swing state polls has shown strength, often outperforming Joe Biden in the presidential race.

The Crystal Ball will continue monitoring the Senate races closely, providing updates and analysis as the election season progresses. With Montana now leaning towards the Republican party, the battle for Senate control becomes even more crucial for both sides.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related