****

As Hurricane Milton nears Florida's west coast, it threatens to unleash billions of dollars in damage that could disrupt the state's already vulnerable insurance market and economy. With the insurance sector grappling with soaring premiums and the withdrawal of insurers from the state, a storm of Milton's magnitude could reverse any recent stabilization efforts.

“This is the worst-case scenario,” expressed Jeff Brandes, president of the Florida Policy Project. The hurricane is expected to hit as a powerful Category 4, bringing massive storm surges and violent winds to a heavily populated Gulf Coast area. The impending disaster has prompted mass evacuations in preparation for what could be a catastrophic event.

This is the second major hurricane to strike Florida this year, following Hurricane Helene, which recently caused significant flooding in Pinellas County. Helene racked up $11 billion in insured losses nationwide, with more than $1 billion attributed to Florida alone. Estimates suggest that Milton's impact could far exceed these figures, with potential losses surpassing $50 billion.

The timing is particularly precarious for Florida's insurance market, which only recently began to show signs of stabilization after years of turmoil. Past natural disasters and legal battles have already led to the collapse of several insurers, while others have significantly increased premiums and reduced coverage. The state-formed Citizens Property Insurance, intended as an insurer of last resort, has seen rapid expansion due to limited options for residents.

Legislative measures introduced in late 2022 aimed to ease the crisis by limiting lawsuits against insurers, which some argue saved the industry. However, there's been criticism that these changes overly favored insurance companies. Representative Matt Gaetz recently criticized state legislators for being too beholden to the insurance industry, suggesting significant reforms are still needed.

As Milton looms, questions linger about the resilience of smaller, Florida-specific insurers. AM Best, an insurance rating agency, has warned that combined losses from Helene and Milton could devastate some companies. The impact of these back-to-back storms could potentially negate recent industry improvements.

Despite concerns, some experts remain cautiously optimistic. Mark Friedlander of the Insurance Information Institute believes that Florida insurers are well-prepared to handle the influx of claims associated with Hurricane Milton. However, he also noted that only about 20% of Florida homeowners have flood insurance, amplifying the potential economic strain.

The long-term implications of Milton could extend into the national arena, potentially reviving discussions in Washington, D.C. about the necessity of a national catastrophe insurance program. House Speaker Mike Johnson highlighted the importance of protecting coastal communities, underlining the gravity of recurring natural disasters in regions like Florida and Louisiana.

The financial health of Citizens Property Insurance is also under scrutiny, especially with its $6 billion surplus and substantial reinsurance coverage. However, should these resources deplete, a statewide insurance surcharge—dubbed the "hurricane tax"—could be instituted, impacting all policyholders.

In summary, Hurricane Milton stands poised to test the stability and resilience of Florida's insurance market, raising concerns about immediate and long-term economic impacts. The outcome of this storm may significantly influence future legislative and insurance industry actions, aimed at safeguarding residents and their properties in this storm-prone state.