****

The White House budget director, Russ Vought, has dismissed fears regarding potential premature deaths due to cuts in benefits from a recent spending bill as "totally ridiculous." The bill, named Donald Trump's One Big Beautiful Bill, is awaiting debate in the US Senate. It proposes significant reductions to key federal safety net programs, including Medicaid, which assists low-income and disabled individuals, and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (Snap), which helps Americans afford food.

On CNN's "State of the Union," Vought defended the bill, arguing that the concerns are overblown and rooted in "astroturf" opposition. He maintained that the bill aims to preserve and protect social safety net programs while implementing more commonsense approaches. Vought also supported the proposed restructuring of the federal workforce under Elon Musk's "Department of Government Efficiency" (Doge).

The bill has ignited considerable controversy, especially in light of a recent town hall meeting in Iowa hosted by Senator Joni Ernst. When a constituent expressed fears that cuts to Medicaid would lead to deaths, Ernst responded dismissively, earning jeers and online backlash. She later posted a sarcastic apology video, which further fueled the debate.

Advocacy groups have voiced strong opposition to the proposed cuts. The Ohio Nurses Association warned that the reductions would not just cause hardship but actually result in deaths. The American Academy of Pediatrics predicted that the bill would lead to more hungry children and difficult choices for families, while the American Hospital Association cautioned that rural hospitals might be forced to close.

Prominent Democrats have also been vocal in their criticism. Senator Chris Murphy of Connecticut condemned the bill on CNN, stating that it prioritizes tax cuts for the wealthy at the expense of public health and would contribute to the U.S. deficit. He argued that people losing health insurance would indeed result in more deaths. Georgia Senator Raphael Warnock echoed these concerns on NBC's "Meet the Press," asserting that the bill's work-reporting requirement for Medicaid recipients is more likely to strip people of their healthcare than to incentivize work.

Supporters of the bill, such as House Speaker Mike Johnson, insist that the legislation does not cut Medicaid but rather aims to eliminate "fraud, waste, and abuse" within the system. Despite passing the House, the bill faces significant opposition in the Republican-controlled Senate. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries predicted that the bill would not pass, warning of severe consequences including the closure of hospitals and nursing homes, and potentially resulting in deaths.

As the debate moves to the Senate, the bill's fate remains uncertain, but it has undoubtedly spotlighted deep divisions over the future of America's social safety net.