In a rapidly escalating Israel-Hamas conflict, French President Emmanuel Macron finds himself at the center of criticism for sending mixed messages regarding France's position. While Macron's recent statements have been seen as taking a tougher stance on Israel, they have also sparked controversy and incomprehension, risking turning many against him.

The disagreement between Macron and Israeli President Isaac Herzog further highlights the confusion surrounding France's stance. Herzog claimed Macron emphasized France's unequivocal support for Israel's right and duty to self-defense. However, French diplomats, speaking anonymously, denied this statement, instead stressing the importance of Israel adhering to the rules of war.

France, historically seen as one of the Western countries most attentive to Arab concerns, initially drew criticism in the Middle East for its perceived pro-Israeli position during the early days of the conflict. This contradiction with Paris' diplomatic tradition raised concerns among parts of French diplomacy and drew disapproval in the region. Despite being one of the last Western leaders to visit Israel, Macron's stance invited protests in Tunisia and Lebanon, countries where France is usually viewed more favorably.

An anonymous French diplomat refuted claims that Macron was shifting his position on Israel. However, they acknowledged that his statements were in response to the evolving situation on the ground. The diplomat emphasized that while Israel has the right to defend itself, it must also respect international rules, which they believe is not currently happening, referencing the Israeli bombing campaign.

French Armed Forces Minister Sébastien Lecornu attempted to explain Macron's thinking during a TV interview but did not backtrack on the French president's comments regarding Palestinian civilians. Lecornu reaffirmed that Macron's stance aligns with France's long-standing commitment to a two-state solution and highlighted Macron's personal engagement with both Israel and the West Bank.

Lecornu also acknowledged the delicate position that France finds itself in, with critics blaming the country for trying to maintain a position of equilibrium. He reiterated that France believes Israel should have the ability to defend itself, especially in the face of Hamas using civilians as human shields, but stressed the need to protect the lives of Palestinian civilians.

French diplomats noted that their concerns for Palestinian lives are shared by others internationally. United States Secretary of State Anthony Blinken recently expressed his concerns about the high number of Palestinian casualties and called for increased efforts to protect civilians.

As the Israel-Hamas conflict continues, Macron's handling of France's position faces growing scrutiny. The president's nuanced approach, rooted in the country's historic diplomatic tradition, seeks to balance support for Israel's right to self-defense with the imperative to protect Palestinian civilians. However, the conflicting narratives and heightened tensions challenge Macron's ability to navigate this complex issue while maintaining the respect and understanding of all parties involved.