Preseason Coaches Poll Reveals Surprises: Michigan Overrated, Missouri Underrated
ICARO Media Group
The release of the preseason Coaches Poll has brought some interesting surprises as college football fans eagerly await the start of the 2024 season. The rankings are in, and while traditional powerhouses like Georgia, Ohio State, and Texas claimed the top spots, there were a few teams that stood out as either overrated or underrated.
Starting with the overrated category, reigning national champions, Michigan, find themselves placed at a lofty No. 8 despite significant losses from last season. After bidding farewell to head coach Jim Harbaugh, along with several key players on offense and defense, the Wolverines face an uphill battle to maintain their championship-caliber performance. With star quarterback J.J. McCarthy and running back Blake Corum gone, Michigan's offensive firepower has taken a hit. Additionally, the departures of key defensive leaders Junior Colson and Mike Sainristil raise questions about the team's defensive strength. It is worth noting that this is the first time since 1997 that a coach has left a title-winning team, adding to the uncertainty surrounding Michigan's prospects.
On the other hand, the preseason rankings also reflected some teams being underrated, with Missouri claiming the spotlight. Despite an impressive 11-win season and a significant victory over Ohio State in the Cotton Bowl, Missouri finds itself ranked at No. 11. The Tigers' stellar performance last year, led by standout wide receiver Luther Burden III, showcased their potential to compete at a higher level. With a roster boasting immense talent, Missouri has all the ingredients to establish themselves as a top-10 team this season. Their manageable schedule further enhances their chances of repeating last year's success in the tough SEC.
Florida State, on the other hand, is another team that has been placed below their potential at No. 10. While the Seminoles have made improvements since their lopsided Orange Bowl defeat to Georgia, the departure of many key offensive players poses challenges for the upcoming season. With their top quarterback, running back, tight end, and two top receivers no longer with the team, Florida State faces a considerable rebuilding effort. Despite the addition of several talented transfers, it is difficult to justify placing them ahead of teams like Missouri, Utah, or even Tennessee, all of whom seem better positioned heading into the season.
Meanwhile, SMU, fresh off a conference championship season, finds themselves surprisingly absent from the top 25. Despite returning a majority of their production from last year, including underrated quarterback Preston Stone and a formidable defense, the Mustangs have been overlooked by the voters. Adjusting to their new challenge as a member of the ACC, SMU's 0-5 record against power-conference teams over the past two seasons raises valid concerns. However, with a talented roster and an impressive secondary, expect the Mustangs to prove their worth and defy expectations.
The preseason Coaches Poll serves as a starting point for the college football season, offering a glimpse into how teams are perceived going into the year. While some teams may find themselves overrated or underrated at this stage, only time will reveal the true strength of each program. As the countdown to kickoff continues, football fans eagerly anticipate the excitement, surprises, and upsets that college football reliably delivers.