Pitcher Injuries Plague Major League Baseball, Threatening Stars and Fantasy Strategies
ICARO Media Group
Injuries continue to mount for pitchers in Major League Baseball, leaving fans and fantasy managers concerned about the fate of some of the game's biggest stars. A slew of veteran pitchers, including Jacob deGrom, Justin Verlander, Max Scherzer, and Clayton Kershaw, were already sidelined at the start of the 2024 season, raising alarms about the state of pitchers' health.
The latest blow came with the news that Shane Bieber, last year's Cy Young winner, will undergo Tommy John surgery, ruling him out for the entire season. Alongside Bieber, young phenom Spencer Strider also faces an uncertain future due to injury concerns. The already extensive list of injured pitchers was exacerbated by a string of unfortunate incidents during spring training, which impacted Gerrit Cole, Devin Williams, Eury Pérez, Kyle Bradish, and Kodai Senga, among others.
The changing landscape of the pitching role in baseball has contributed to the growing concern. Complete games are becoming rare, with some pitchers only expected to work through a lineup a few times before being relieved by the bullpen. This shift in approach aims to preserve the arms of pitchers, but the results have been marginal at best.
The baseball industry grapples with the complex task of safeguarding pitchers, but finding a solution remains challenging. While many acknowledge that prioritizing velocity and spin rate may not be sustainable in the long run, it becomes difficult to ask pitchers to abandon what makes them effective on the mound. Additionally, the stark reality remains that max effort and speed can often be the determining factors between making it to the major leagues or not.
For fantasy managers, navigating the landscape of pitching injuries becomes a daunting task. The preseason strategy of relying on low-walk, modest-strikeout pitchers as reliable options has not panned out, as pitchers like Logan Webb, George Kirby, and Chris Bassitt have struggled early on. Even seemingly safe options like Webb and Bassitt, who previously underwent Tommy John surgery, showcase the unpredictability of pitching injuries.
In search of value, fantasy managers may turn to late-round pitching options, seeking potential breakouts or pitchers who excel in specific matchups. The Boston Red Sox rotation, featuring Nick Pivetta, Kutter Crawford, and Tanner Houck, has shown promise, albeit against weaker offenses. Yoshinobu Yamamoto and Shota Imanaga have also generated buzz, displaying impressive strikeout-to-walk ratios. Breakout candidates such as Garrett Crochet, Jared Jones, and Brandon Pfaadt, along with established pitchers like Jack Flaherty and Jordan Hicks, offer glimpses of optimism in an otherwise uncertain landscape.
The devastating loss of Shane Bieber, whose dominance was on full display with 20 strikeouts in two starts, serves as a painful reminder of the fragility of pitching excellence. While the road to recovery may be long, fans can find solace in the hope of seeing perennial stars like Kershaw, Verlander, and Scherzer back in action later this year. The return of deGrom and the imminent arrival of Walker Buehler add further anticipation to the pitching landscape.
As the season progresses, fantasy managers must adapt and make informed decisions to counter the wave of injuries. Building a bench of promising pitchers with upside becomes crucial, while monitoring favorable matchups and pitchers who excel in specific areas can yield valuable contributions. A touch of luck may ultimately determine success in navigating the turbulent pitching landscape.
Despite the challenges and uncertainties surrounding pitcher injuries, the love for baseball endures. Fans and fantasy managers hold onto cherished memories of pitchers commanding the mound with grace and dominance, eagerly awaiting the return of their favorite aces.