In a unanimous vote on Monday, the NFL announced the banning of the hip-drop tackle, a decision aimed at enhancing player safety. While the league claims this move is necessary to reduce injuries, the ruling has sparked strong reactions from players past and present.

Detractors argue that this rule change will have negative implications on the game, fundamentally altering the way it is played. Critics also contend that it further favors offenses and protects the league's marketable players. Last week, the NFL Players Association (NFLPA) voiced its concerns about the proposal, citing confusion for players, coaches, officials, and fans.

Supporting the ban, NFL's competition committee executive vice president, Jeff Miller, stressed the higher rate of injuries associated with hip-drop tackles, which are about 25 times more likely to cause harm compared to conventional tackles. Ultimately, his argument prevailed, leading team owners to officially vote in favor of the ban at the league meetings in Orlando.

Following the decision, players took to social media to express their opinions. J.J. Watt, a retired three-time defensive player of the year, labeled the ban as turning the game into flag football, echoing the sentiment of many critics.

However, not all players were against the change. Running back Kenyan Drake, who suffered a fractured ankle in 2021, supported the rule, stating that he had personally experienced the consequences of such tackles and was relieved that others would be spared. Retired Pro Bowl tackle Kyle Long also applauded the league's efforts to prioritize player safety.

Former New England Patriots receiver Julian Edelman took a balanced approach, acknowledging the dangers of hip-drop tackles while also questioning how defensive players can effectively tackle if various methods are eliminated.

Although there were supporters of the ban, the majority of players on social media expressed their dissatisfaction with the decision. Many high-profile defenders, both past and present, criticized the lack of clarity on how defensive players should tackle ball carriers. They called on the NFL to provide concrete examples and create a video demonstrating the expected technique.

The banning of the hip-drop tackle marks a significant change in the NFL's rulebook, aiming to improve player safety. However, this decision has ignited intense debate among players, demonstrating the polarized perspectives on the issue. As the league adjusts to the new rule, it remains to be seen how it will impact the game and player performance moving forward.