In an exclusive mock draft by NFL Network insider Pete Schrager, the New York Giants are predicted to make a bold move by trading up with the Arizona Cardinals to secure the fourth overall pick and select quarterback J.J. McCarthy from Michigan. Schrager's projection is based on weeks of conversations with NFL general managers and head coaches, indicating that there is substantial interest in this potential trade.

If this mock draft comes to fruition, the New York Giants would trade their third-round pick in this year's draft (No. 70 overall) and next year's second-round pick to Arizona in exchange for the opportunity to select McCarthy. The move would signify the Giants' intent to move on from current quarterback Daniel Jones, as McCarthy checks all the necessary boxes for their future plans.

According to Schrager, Joe Schoen, the general manager of the Giants, has been diligently evaluating quarterback prospects, recognizing the team's need to find a franchise quarterback. McCarthy, touted as Schrager's QB2 in this year's draft, possesses exceptional field vision, processing speed, accuracy, and arm strength. His performance in high-pressure situations has set him apart from other contenders.

Although McCarthy did not receive much media attention before Michigan's championship run, experts believe that NFL scouts have been closely monitoring him throughout the season. With a supportive environment and a coaching staff including Brian Daboll, Mike Kafka, and Shea Tierney, the Giants present a promising platform for McCarthy's development.

Critics argue that the Giants' roster does not require such a drastic move at the expense of a third-round pick. They highlight the underrated potential of receivers Darius Slayton, Jalin Hyatt, and Wan'Dale Robinson, as well as the solid performance of the offensive line. However, Schrager emphasizes the long-term benefits of acquiring McCarthy, allowing the Giants to build a stronger foundation for 2025 and beyond.

With the potential acquisition of McCarthy, the Giants could possess their quarterback of the future and a talented receiver comparable to those drafted in the top six this year. Additionally, greater salary cap flexibility and future trade assets could be obtained by potentially trading Daniel Jones to a quarterback-needy team next year.

As the 2024 NFL Draft approaches, the Giants' interest in securing J.J. McCarthy as their future quarterback has generated significant buzz. Fans and analysts alike eagerly await the official announcement to see if Schrager's bold projection will come to pass and whether McCarthy will be donning the blue and white jersey of the New York Giants in the upcoming season.