In a survey of 14 media sources, the Dolphins achieved an average GPA of 2.7, equivalent to a B-minus average.

One major highlight for the Dolphins was their focus on bolstering both their offensive and defensive lines in the early stages of the draft. In the first round, Miami selected edge rusher Chop Robinson, who impressed experts with his explosive abilities off the ball. Offensive tackle Patrick Paul was then chosen in the second round, a selection seen as a potential replacement for veteran left tackle Terron Armstead.

However, some experts questioned certain aspects of the Dolphins' draft strategy. The decision to trade up for a fourth-round pick and select running back Jaylen Wright sparked debate, considering the team already had a crowded running back room. Despite this, many analysts acknowledged Wright's potential as a big-play runner.

One recurring theme in the criticism was the Dolphins' lack of focus on specific team needs. While some media outlets praised the team's addition of promising players, especially in the later rounds, they felt the Dolphins may have prioritized value over addressing crucial areas of concern, such as their offensive interior and secondary.

The forfeiture of the Dolphins' third-round pick due to an owner tampering violation also influenced overall evaluations of the team's draft class. Trading a future third-round pick for a fourth-round selection in the current draft was seen as a risky move.

Nonetheless, some media sources expressed optimism about the Dolphins' draft class and highlighted individual players' potential. Edge rusher Chop Robinson was hailed as having the potential to become the AP Defensive Rookie of the Year, while sixth-round wide receiver Malik Washington was considered a sleeper pick.

Overall, the Miami Dolphins' 2024 draft class received a mix of grades. While none of the media outlets bestowed grades higher than a B-plus, the team avoided any ratings below a C. The varying assessments likely reflect the different priorities and perspectives among analysts.

The Dolphins will be closely watched as the drafted players join the team and start their professional careers. Only time will tell if the draft class lives up to its potential and helps propel the Dolphins to success in the upcoming NFL season.