In a shocking revelation, finance researcher Stewart Brown's recent paper highlights a financial anomaly that has remained unsolved for decades. Despite the availability of low-fee index funds that consistently outperform managed funds, investors continue to pour billions of dollars into underperforming mutual funds, paying exorbitant fees in the process.

According to Brown's research, investors paid approximately $90 billion in fees on around $14 trillion of actively managed mutual funds in 2021 alone. This alarming figure raises questions about why investors choose to stick with managed funds when index funds not only offer better performance but also come at a much lower cost.

The distinction between actively managed funds and passively managed funds is key to understanding this predicament. Actively managed funds employ money managers who carefully analyze potential investments and make strategic buying and selling decisions on behalf of shareholders. However, the research suggests that the expertise provided by these managers often falls short of producing superior returns.

On the other hand, passively managed funds, such as index funds, seek to mirror the performance of a specific index by holding a similar basket of securities in the same proportions. The fees associated with index funds tend to be significantly lower, making them an attractive option for investors looking for consistent returns.

For instance, an S&P 500 index fund like the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO) aims to deliver returns that closely match the S&P 500. This widely recognized index has historically averaged annual returns of nearly 10%. Considering the power of consistent gains like these, it's puzzling why investors continue to opt for managed funds with their inferior performance and higher fees.

This financial mystery was first identified by fellow researcher Gruber in 1996, and despite decades of analysis, experts have made little progress in understanding the persistence of this trend.

As investors become more aware of the substantial advantages presented by low-fee index funds, it is imperative that they reevaluate their investment strategies. While the allure of managed funds and the hope for superior returns may be tempting, the data overwhelmingly supports the performance and cost-effectiveness of index funds.

With billions of dollars at stake, investors need to ask themselves why they would choose to pay more and receive subpar results when a more affordable and superior alternative exists. It is time for investors to consider shifting their focus towards index funds and embrace the opportunities they offer for long-term growth and financial success.

Disclaimer: This article contains opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool's Premium Investing Services. To access their expert recommendations and more in-depth research, become a Motley Fool member today.