Financial Advisors Reluctant to Recommend Bitcoin ETFs Despite Success in the Market
ICARO Media Group
In the world of cryptocurrency, the launch of bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) was anticipated to be a game-changer for financial advisors, who hoped to have regulated funds that would enable them to guide their clients towards investing in bitcoin. However, six months since the introduction of these ETFs, there seems to be little enthusiasm among advisors to embrace them. Many remain cautious and skeptical about bitcoin's high-risk and speculative nature, while others are preparing for the day when they will recommend it, believing it to be inevitable.
According to a survey conducted by the CNBC Advisor Council, financial planners are largely refraining from initiating discussions or fielding client inquiries about bitcoin ETFs. Furthermore, it was found that most advisors only have one client, if any, who has invested in these funds. The survey featured insights from a dozen council members, revealing that concerns over time in the market and regulatory compliance are the two primary reasons for their apprehension.
The regulated nature of bitcoin ETFs was expected to encourage greater adoption among financial advisors. BlackRock's iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT) has already amassed an impressive $20 billion in assets under management, despite advisors' reluctance to engage with the cryptocurrency. However, advisors like Lee Baker, founder and president of Apex Financial Services, are cautiously researching bitcoin but have yet to recommend it to their clients. Baker highlights the need for a more extensive track record to enhance the chances of including bitcoin in client portfolios.
The resistance to bitcoin ETFs can be attributed to bitcoin's inherent volatility. While the cryptocurrency has shown remarkable growth, with a 59% increase this year alone and gains of 230% from its 2022 low, it has also experienced significant drawdowns of up to 70% in the past. This level of volatility is a deterrent for many financial advisors who prioritize stability and long-term growth for their clients. They hope that consistent flows into bitcoin ETFs in the coming years will help stabilize its performance and decrease volatility.
Indeed, as time passes and the cryptocurrency matures, financial advisors anticipate being able to model bitcoin's performance similarly to other asset classes such as stocks and bonds. This modeling would enable advisors to make more informed recommendations to their clients, fostering greater acceptance of bitcoin ETFs. Despite the current slow uptake, advisors believe that embracing bitcoin is a matter of "when" rather than "if".
In addition to concerns over volatility, the lack of regulatory clarity surrounding bitcoin remains a significant deterrent for financial advisors. While bitcoin ETFs are now regulated investment vehicles, there is still uncertainty regarding when and if advisors can recommend them. Compliance offices and broker-dealers impose restrictions on the allocation of bitcoin ETFs, driven by concerns about fraud, scandals, and potential fines from regulatory bodies like the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).
To instill confidence among clients and gain wider adoption, bitcoin and its ETFs need more time in the market. Larger players like Vanguard have expressed a hesitancy to offer bitcoin ETFs until the asset evolves to become less speculative. Financial advisors believe that with time, trust in bitcoin will grow as exchanges mature and regulatory frameworks solidify, paving the way for wider acceptance.
While financial advisors remain cautious, the introduction of spot ether ETFs by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) last week adds a new layer of complexity. Although some investors anticipate success for ether ETFs, advisors are likely to be even more hesitant due to the additional intricacies of this cryptocurrency's use cases and functionality.
In conclusion, despite the success of bitcoin ETFs in the market, financial advisors are still reluctant to recommend them to their clients. Concerns over volatility, regulatory compliance, and the need for a longer track record are major factors contributing to this hesitation. Advisors anticipate a gradual adoption of bitcoin ETFs in the coming years as confidence builds and the industry matures.