Suozzi campaigned on tougher border enforcement, causing worry among members of the party. Rep. Lou Correa voiced concerns about Suozzi's focus on immigration, stating that while Suozzi's victory is positive, his emphasis on this issue could be detrimental to the party. Correa highlighted the confusion among Latinos in his district regarding immigration policies and the challenges of reconciling differing viewpoints within the party.

During his campaign, Suozzi debated Republican Mazi Pilip and expressed support for comprehensive immigration solutions, including proposals such as increasing border security measures and providing assistance for asylum seekers. Suozzi's campaign ads emphasized securing the border and praised ICE as a crucial agency, further sparking debate within the party.

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez also raised concerns about the party's stance on immigration following Suozzi's victory. Despite some immigration advocacy groups taking issue with Suozzi's campaign promises, America's Voice commended his approach in addressing border concerns while also advocating for broader immigration reform. Vanessa Cárdenas, Executive Director of America's Voice, noted Suozzi's full support for citizenship and legal status for long-settled immigrants as a positive aspect of his platform.

Suozzi's victory in New York has prompted discussions within the Democratic party about the balance between border security and compassionate immigration policies, reflecting the ongoing challenges in navigating the complexities of this issue.