In Stillwater, Oklahoma, the Utah football team faced a pivotal conference opener against No. 14 Oklahoma State. All eyes were on seventh-year quarterback Cam Rising, who had missed the last two games due to a hand injury. Rising was seen warming up on the field, sparking hopes of his return to the starting lineup. However, to the surprise of many, freshman Isaac Wilson took the field as the starting quarterback for the undefeated Utah team.

Despite Rising being fully dressed and participating in pre-game warmups, it was Wilson who led the Utes to a hard-fought 22-19 victory over Oklahoma State. While questions swirled around Rising's readiness to play, Coach Whittingham remained tight-lipped about the situation, only stating that the decision not to play Rising was made just minutes before kickoff. Wilson demonstrated composure and determination in his second career start, becoming the first true freshman quarterback in Utah's program history to defeat an AP ranked team.

The Utah defense showcased its strength by limiting Oklahoma State to 285 total yards while keeping their starting quarterback in check. Defensive coordinator Morgan Scalley's strategic preparation and the team's defensive culture played a significant role in stifling the Cowboys' offense. Despite facing challenges, Utah's defense dominated for the majority of the game, closing out plays when it mattered most. With key contributions from players like Smith Snowden, the defense was instrumental in securing the crucial conference victory for the Utes.