USC Faces Backlash and Controversy as Valedictorian Slot Withdrawn Amidst Heightened Campus Tensions
ICARO Media Group
In an unexpected turn of events, the University of Southern California (USC) has faced a wave of protests, controversy, and arrests after revoking the graduation speaking slot of the valedictorian, Asna Tabassum. This decision was made in response to undisclosed threats, leading to the cancellation of USC's largest graduation event.
Asna Tabassum, a hijab-wearing Muslim daughter of Indian immigrants, had been selected for the prestigious valedictorian role from a pool of nearly 100 applicants with exceptional academic achievements and extracurricular activities. Her selection showcased USC's commitment to diversity and academic excellence. However, the decision to withdraw her speaking slot has sparked outrage and widespread condemnation.
The cancellation of the main commencement ceremony, which typically attracts around 65,000 attendees, makes USC the only university to take such drastic measures. Additionally, the campus gates have been closed to the public, resulting in 93 arrests. Many classes have been moved online, creating further disruptions for students.
Critics argue that USC's administration has mishandled the situation at every step, with bestselling novelist and university professor, Viet Thanh Nguyen, describing it as a "complete disaster." Gabriel Kahn, a USC professor of journalism, echoed this sentiment, highlighting the university's failure to initiate constructive dialogue and exhibit leadership during times of controversy.
USC President Carol Folt, who had remained silent on the matter until now, released a letter acknowledging the difficulties faced by the university community and urged individuals to engage in open discussions and support one another. Despite this, Folt declined interview requests from the media, as did USC board chair Suzanne Nora Johnson.
The controversy surrounding Tabassum's selection arose when pro-Israel groups raised concerns about a pro-Palestinian link on her Instagram profile, criticizing USC for alleged antisemitism. The university cited security concerns as the reason for withdrawing Tabassum's speaking slot, although specific details regarding the threats have not been disclosed.
Faculty, administrators, and parents questioned why the selection process did not include vetting of social media. Many see this decision as an attempt to avoid congressional hearings on antisemitism, which have previously impacted other universities.
Since the incident, numerous protests in support of Tabassum have occurred on USC's campus. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) have offered their assistance to Tabassum, further escalating the situation.
As tensions continue to rise, USC canceled additional commencement speakers, including director Jon M. Chu of "Crazy Rich Asians" and the awarding of honorary degrees. The university cited concerns about putting these guests in an uncomfortable position amidst the ongoing controversy.
The repercussions of this incident extend beyond the cancellation of events. USC's relationship with its Muslim community, which had already faced allegations of bias, has been strained further. Members of the Advisory Committee on Muslim Life at USC resigned after their plea to reconsider Tabassum's revocation went unanswered.
The USC crisis highlights the challenges faced by universities in addressing and managing controversial issues. As these tensions persist, it remains to be seen how USC will navigate this situation and work towards rebuilding a sense of unity and inclusion within its community.