Underperformance and Missed Opportunities: Analyzing James Franklin's Reign at Penn State

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/16388130/original/open-uri20241102-18-1mghebc?1730585832
ICARO Media Group
Politics
02/11/2024 22h10

### Penn State Disappointment Reflects James Franklin's Tenure

Penn State's hopes of making a significant impact this season and securing a spot in the College Football Playoff remain distant under James Franklin's stewardship. The Nittany Lions have consistently faltered in high-stakes situations, a pattern that was painfully evident in their recent defeat to Ohio State.

Facing Ohio State, Penn State had a golden chance to change the narrative. Trailing 20-13 late in the fourth quarter, Penn State found themselves with a first-and-goal opportunity at the 3-yard line. What followed was a series of plays that epitomized Franklin's tenure. Three straight attempts to move forward with Kaytron Allen resulted in mere inches gained. On a do-or-die fourth down, quarterback Drew Allar was forced into a tight, pressured throw, which fell incomplete. This failed drive sealed Penn State's fate, marking the 12th loss to Ohio State in the last 13 years.

Franklin's predictable and risk-averse play-calling in critical moments has been a recurring issue. Since his notable victory over Ohio State in 2016, Franklin has managed to defeat only two top-10 teams: Wisconsin in the Big Ten championship the same year, and Utah in the 2022 Rose Bowl, where the Utes lost their quarterback during the third quarter.

Supporters of Franklin point to his 28-6 record over the last three seasons as evidence of success. Yet, critics argue that merely beating lower-tier Big Ten teams like Washington, Purdue, Minnesota, and Maryland isn't enough to warrant serious national title consideration.

The larger issue may be Penn State's long-term commitment to Franklin, illustrated by his 10-year contract worth $8.5 million annually, running through the 2031 season. The cost of firing Franklin, set at $56.7 million, adds another layer of complexity, potentially deterring any administrative moves to replace him.

While Franklin's teams can capitalize on favorable schedules, including this year’s absence of tougher opponents like Oregon and Indiana, they consistently fall short against formidable competition. This season’s missed opportunity at the 3-yard line against Ohio State serves as a stark reminder of Franklin’s tenure – promising but ultimately unsatisfying in the most crucial moments.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related