UN's Top Court Orders Israel to Halt Military Operation in Gaza City
ICARO Media Group
The International Court of Justice (ICJ), the highest judicial body of the United Nations, has issued a ruling ordering Israel to immediately cease its military operation in the southern Gaza city of Rafah. The court's president, Judge Nawaf Salam, declared that Israel must halt its offensive in Rafah to prevent the physical destruction of the Palestinian population.
The ICJ expressed deep concern over the humanitarian crisis unfolding in Rafah, describing the situation as "disastrous." UN officials have warned of further intensification if the Israeli operation continues. Since the start of the limited ground offensive on May 7, approximately 800,000 Palestinians have been displaced, out of a population of over a million.
Parallel to the military operation, Israel seized Rafah's border crossing with Egypt upon entering the city. This closure has severely hindered the entry of vital humanitarian aid. In response, the ICJ ordered Israel to reopen the Rafah crossing and provide sufficient evacuation and living conditions for the Palestinian population.
Israeli officials have vehemently criticized the ICJ's ruling. Opposition party leader Yair Lapid lamented the court's failure to connect the end of the operation with the release of hostages and Israel's right to defend itself against terror. Former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett took to social media to condemn the ruling, claiming it provided a method for terrorist organizations to evade accountability.
While Hamas welcomed the court's decision, it expressed disappointment that the order only addressed Rafah and not the broader situation in the Gaza Strip. It called for similar attention to be given to other cities like Jabalya, highlighting their dire conditions.
Adding to the international pressure Israel faces, South Africa filed a request for additional measures against Israel, accusing it of endangering civilian life through forced evacuations in Rafah. The request forms part of a larger case alleging Israeli genocide against Palestinians throughout the conflict. Israel's Deputy Attorney General for International Law, Gilad Noam, refuted the allegations and asked the court to consider the predicament Israel faces.
In response to the ICJ's orders, Israel's National Security Council and Ministry of Foreign Affairs confirmed their commitment to reducing harm to civilians and facilitating humanitarian aid. However, the statement also emphasized Israel's concern over the ambiguity in the ruling's text.
The ICJ's ruling further exacerbates international and domestic pressure on Israel to end the war in Gaza. The International Criminal Court (ICC) prosecutor had recently sought arrest warrants for both Hamas leaders and Israeli officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, on charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity. Families of Israeli hostages released distressing footage to pressure Netanyahu into bringing the captives home.
The response from Israel's closest ally, the United States, remains uncertain. While the Biden administration has spoken out against the genocide case, it has cautioned against major ground offensives without a credible plan to protect civilians. The US recently halted arms shipments to Israel amid concerns of their potential use in Rafah against non-combatants.
The ICJ's order places Israel under significant pressure to scale down its operations in Gaza. Prime Minister Netanyahu, however, reiterates Israel's commitment to self-defense, even if forced to stand alone. Israel maintains that Rafah is Hamas's last stronghold, where the group launched an attack on Israel in October, leading to the subsequent war resulting in thousands of casualties.
The mounting international pressure and unprecedented criticism faced by Israel throughout this conflict have raised concerns about its reputation. Experts suggest that these circumstances may also undermine Israel's own judiciary. As top Israeli officials face potential indictment from the ICC, Israel's Attorney General and State Attorney express confidence in the ability of the country's judicial system to address such cases effectively.