****

In a surprising turn, democratic socialist Zohran Mamdani has climbed to second place in the New York City mayoral race by promising ambitious reforms such as free bus services, city-run grocery stores, and no-cost childcare. However, Mamdani faces a significant challenge: financing these extensive programs. He aims to generate $10 billion in new revenue through increased taxes on wealthy individuals and businesses, an approach that may clash with current state policies and political realities.

Governor Kathy Hochul, a moderate Democrat, has expressed strong opposition to raising taxes on high-income earners, fearing it might prompt an exodus to lower-tax states. As Mamdani's plans hinge on the state's cooperation, particularly the governor's, his ambitious proposals seem in jeopardy, especially with Hochul's re-election campaign looming.

A meticulous review by POLITICO has revealed that Mamdani might have significantly underestimated the costs of his housing and school rehabilitation plans by tens of billions of dollars. Additionally, his approach of taxing corporations seems to downplay their existing financial burdens. Former Gov. David Paterson skeptically pointed out the unrealistic nature of Mamdani’s financial estimations, likening them to a child's belief in Santa Claus.

The mayoral race highlights a crucial question: Can a socialist lawmaker, accustomed to advocacy, pivot to the pragmatic rigor required for an executive role? Mamdani’s campaign, rich with social media buzz and grassroots support, has propelled him past other left-leaning candidates, although he still trails the frontrunner, Andrew Cuomo.

Mamdani proposes several methods to generate the $10 billion needed for his agenda: increasing the state's corporate tax rate from 7.25% to 11.5%, imposing a 2% flat tax on the top percentile of New York City income earners, and reforming procurement alongside collecting owed fines and fees. He argues these measures would transform New York City into a place where residents can afford their living expenses and enjoy a higher quality of life.

However, state lawmakers have historically found increasing taxes on the wealthy favorable, but the governor's support remains dubious. Hochul's recent statements emphasize her preference for lowering income taxes to retain wealthy residents in the state. Moreover, New York City's businesses face significant tax obligations already, including city-specific corporate taxes and contributions to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, leading some experts to warn that Mamdani's proposed tax hikes could drive away corporations and jobs.

Mamdani's plan includes expansive proposals like free buses, which would cost around $900 million annually according to the latest estimates, and universal childcare, projected to require between $5 billion to $7 billion yearly. Additionally, Mamdani’s ambitious housing and school rehabilitation plans could substantially inflate the city's debt unless he secures approval to surpass current borrowing limits.

Despite the financial and political hurdles, Mamdani's bold ideas have captured the electorate's imagination. Democratic consultant Trip Yang notes that voters are more drawn to visionary plans that resonate with their aspirations rather than the logistics of funding them, giving Mamdani's campaign a compelling edge in the race.