Portland Grapples with Supreme Court Ruling on Homeless Camping Laws

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/16281339/original/open-uri20240703-18-6g58hc?1720035196
ICARO Media Group
Politics
03/07/2024 19h27

In the wake of a landmark Supreme Court ruling granting cities the authority to penalize individuals for living outside, Portland finds itself navigating the implications for Oregon's largest city. However, city leaders stress that the ruling has little impact on Portland due to a state law that restricts their ability to regulate homeless camping. As a result, the focus has shifted towards lobbying the state to adjust or repeal this law to facilitate effective homeless management.

Portland's legislative team contends that the current state law, designed to protect individual rights, hampers the city's efforts to regulate where homeless individuals can rest. While some maintain that the law already provides adequate tools to enforce anti-camping laws, others argue for its amendment or complete repeal.

County Commissioner Sharon Meieran asserts that the city possesses the necessary tools and resources to address homelessness effectively, emphasizing the need to stop making excuses. The U.S. Supreme Court ruling involved Grants Pass and affirmed that anti-camping laws do not violate constitutional protections against cruel and unusual punishment.

House Bill 3115, introduced by Governor Tina Kotek, was intended to serve as a temporary measure if the Supreme Court overturned previous rulings. It stipulates that regulations on public space must be "objectively reasonable" for cities to enforce. Portland tested the boundaries of this law last year with a ban on daytime camping on public property. However, the ban faced legal challenges, leading Portland to repeal it and implement a new policy allowing camping on public property when no shelter beds are available.

The current policy sets clear limitations on camping activities, including restrictions on using propane heaters, digging, starting fires, and blocking access to private property. Violations of these rules can result in fines or jail time, as can the refusal to vacate a camp when shelter space is offered.

Portland Mayor Ted Wheeler views the current policy as a starting point, but emphasizes the need for amendments to the state law to ensure clarity and specific statewide requirements. The mayor's office plans to formally request changes from the state legislature in the coming weeks.

City Commissioner Rene Gonzalez, who is running for mayor, expresses openness to repealing HB 3115 entirely, citing the uncertainty faced by cities when local judges intervene using the law. Gonzalez also contemplates updating the city's camping policy to make it clearer and more easily administered, though specific changes are not outlined.

While some local officials perceive limitations in the state law, County Commissioner Carmen Rubio believes the city can effectively address unsheltered homelessness while tackling its root causes. She emphasizes the need for compassion while holding the line on reasonable restrictions for those who consciously refuse to abide by them.

Multnomah County Chair Jessica Vega Pederson has not commented on lobbying for changes to HB 3115, with Commissioner Meieran deeming it a waste of money. Instead, Meieran contends that the hundreds of millions of dollars allocated through the supportive housing services tax can be harnessed to open more shelters and invest in support services to reduce the number of individuals living on the streets.

Homeless advocacy organizations recognize the state law's flexibility in allowing cities to regulate public camping, but stress the importance of finding permanent housing solutions. The city's anti-camping policy has raised concerns among homeless individuals, as certain options may not work for everyone due to reasons such as trauma or disqualifications based on criminal records.

The Supreme Court ruling is expected to play a significant role in the November elections, where all council seats are up for grabs. Homeless camping policies are likely to be a divisive issue, polarizing discussions between heavy policing advocates and proponents of ceasing sweeps. However, advocates urge a focus on housing as the ultimate solution to homelessness.

As the city awaits potential changes to the state law, the incoming City Council and mayor will play a pivotal role in shaping the city's priorities for the upcoming legislative session.

(Note: The article is generated using only the entities, numbers, and dates mentioned in the provided information. Some paraphrasing and context have been added for coherence.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related