Minnesota Introduces Ban on Shadow Noncompete Clauses, Boosting Worker Opportunities
ICARO Media Group
In a significant move to increase wages and foster competition for workers, the state of Minnesota has implemented a new law banning shadow noncompete clauses. The legislation, which took effect on Monday, aims to empower employees by prohibiting companies from preventing their former employers from hiring them.
The ban specifically targets companies that provide services to other businesses, such as property management firms. This comes as a relief for individuals like Michael Rubke, who works at the front desk of a condominium building in Minneapolis. Rubke was previously unaware that he could be forced to leave his job, regardless of his performance, due to a shadow noncompete clause.
Shadow noncompete clauses are agreements between property management companies and condo associations that restrict the hiring of employees if the management switches. These agreements have been criticized for limiting job opportunities and hindering workers' ability to seek gainful employment in their industry of expertise.
Rubke expressed his satisfaction with the new law, stating, "These restrictive covenants limit the rights of the working class to seek gainful employment in the industries that they know. We, the workers, didn't even know all the places where these covenants existed."
Minnesota's ban on shadow noncompete clauses is an extension of previous efforts by the state Legislature to curtail noncompete practices. In 2020, a law was enacted that prohibited noncompete agreements between employers and employees, which prevented workers from joining competing businesses. This move was followed by the Federal Trade Commission's nationwide ban on most noncompete agreements.
The discovery of shadow noncompete loopholes prompted State Sen. Alice Mann and State Rep. Emma Greenman to co-author the bill to outlaw the practice. Mann noted that many workers were unaware of being affected by such agreements since they appeared in contracts between companies rather than in contracts with employees.
The new law prohibits companies from making contracts that affect future income and livelihood without the knowledge of the individuals involved. Greenman emphasized the significance of employees being able to remain in their buildings, especially in industries such as building services and childcare, where familiarity with residents and neighbors is crucial.
Supporters of the law anticipate that it will create more competitive wages and provide workers with increased options among potential employers. Greenman stated, "We think that this is just common sense for our communities, for our workers, and certainly for competition in our marketplace."
Although the ban does not affect existing shadow noncompete agreements, it will prevent companies from entering into new ones. Rubke expressed hope that employers with standing agreements will choose not to enforce them, further benefiting employees affected by these restrictive clauses.
With the implementation of this ban, Minnesota has taken a significant step in protecting workers' rights, increasing job mobility, and fostering healthy competition in the marketplace.