George R.R. Martin Expresses Disappointment Over House of the Dragon Change
ICARO Media Group
In a recent blog post, acclaimed author George R.R. Martin shared his disappointment with a major change in the television adaptation of his book, "Fire & Blood," impacting the hit series "House of the Dragon." The change revolves around a pivotal scene in Season 2, Episode 1, where the character Jaehaerys is murdered. Martin expressed his preference for the original book version of the scene, which included the presence of Jaehaerys' younger brother, Maelor.
The episode titled "A Son for a Son" showcases the assassination of Jaehaerys by two unnamed assassins, known as "Blood" and "Cheese." In the book, the assassins present a grim choice to Helaena, the mother of the two boys, asking her to choose which son should die. Under duress, Helaena chooses Maelor, leading the killers to spare his life and kill Jaehaerys instead. Martin described this "Sophie's Choice" aspect of the scene as the strongest and most visceral, and was disappointed that it was left out of the adaptation.
Initially resistant to the change, Martin revealed that showrunner Ryan Condal assured him that Maelor would still make an appearance later in the show. However, book readers who are familiar with the fate of Maelor may anticipate a tragic and gruesome end for the character. In the book, Maelor is sent away from King's Landing, only to meet a gruesome demise during his journey, ultimately driving his mother, Helaena, to take her own life. This event is one of the factors that turns the people of Westeros against Rhaenyra.
Martin also shared that in Condal's outline for Season 3, Helaena still kills herself, but without a specific reason or triggering event as in the book. The absence of Maelor in Episode 2 raises questions about the character's future in the show. Martin suggested that the simplest way forward might be to drop the character entirely and make adjustments to the plot accordingly, such as eliminating the storyline where Alicent attempts to send the children to safety.
Responding to Martin's disappointment, an HBO spokesperson expressed their admiration for Martin and his book, and emphasized that showrunners often face difficult choices when adapting a book for the screen. The spokesperson commended Ryan Condal and his team for their extraordinary work, believing that the millions of fans who have followed the series over its first two seasons will continue to enjoy it.
"House of the Dragon" has already incorporated several modifications from the book, including changes to characters like Helaena and Alicent, as well as altered storylines involving Aegon and Aemond. However, Martin's disappointment over the absence of Prince Maelor suggests that this change may have pushed the boundaries for the author.
"House of the Dragon" can be streamed on HBO Max, offering viewers a mix of familiar and adapted storylines from Martin's captivating world of Westeros.