Federal Judge Temporarily Halts Trump Campaign's Use of Hold On, I'm Coming Amid Lawsuit by Isaac Hayes' Estate
ICARO Media Group
In a recent legal battle between the Trump campaign and the estate of Isaac Hayes, a federal judge has issued a preliminary injunction, temporarily halting the campaign's use of the song "Hold On, I'm Coming." U.S. District Judge Thomas Thrash granted the motion for the injunction at a hearing in Atlanta.
The lawsuit, filed by the estate of Isaac Hayes, alleges that the Trump campaign's use of the song at rallies violated their copyright for the work. David Porter, the co-author of the song, also stated that he did not authorize its use. The song, originally recorded by Sam & Dave, has been a staple at Trump campaign events.
The Trump campaign claimed that they had obtained permission to use the song through a BMI license acquired on November 30, 2022. They further argued that the Hayes estate was not the license holder, but rather Universal Music Publishing. However, the Hayes estate disputed this claim, stating that the campaign misinterpreted a 2024 Copyright Office assignment record.
According to the attorneys representing the Hayes estate, the BMI license was terminated almost three months ago via a letter from BMI. Despite this termination, the Trump campaign continued to use the song in their events nearly 30 times.
Upholding the ruling by Judge Thrash, the temporary injunction effectively prohibits the Trump campaign from using "Hold On, I'm Coming" while the case proceeds. In addition to the injunction, the Hayes estate has demanded $3 million in payment for the unauthorized use of the song.
Ronald Coleman, attorney for the Trump campaign, stated that they have no intention of causing annoyance or harm. He mentioned that if the Hayes family feels affected by the use of the song, they will respect their wishes and not force the issue.
However, the judge denied a motion to order the Trump campaign to remove social media and other posts in which the song was used. This matter, along with other issues, will be addressed in the impending trial.
Isaac Hayes III, son of the late musician, expressed gratitude for the judge's decision, saying that it provides an opportunity for other artists who do not wish to have their music associated with Donald Trump or any political entities. Hayes III also revealed that Trump has been using the music for the past four years.
This legal dispute between musicians, artists, and the Trump campaign over the use of music is one of the notable standoffs witnessed in recent times. As the case unfolds, it will shed light on the broader question of copyright infringement and the rights of artists in the political arena.