Contrast in Musical Choices Highlighted at Democratic and Republican National Conventions

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/16329274/original/open-uri20240822-17-1axq0co?1724361029
ICARO Media Group
Politics
22/08/2024 21h05

Last night, the Democratic National Convention in Chicago showcased a star-studded lineup of musicians, delivering an impressive array of performances that any mid-sized festival would envy. From Stevie Wonder's electrifying rendition of "Higher Ground" to John Legend's moving tribute to Prince, the convention boasted an eclectic mix of artists spanning eras and genres. In striking contrast, the recent Republican National Convention in Milwaukee featured a more limited musical selection, leaving music fans with Lee Greenwood, Chris Janson, and Kid Rock as the main attractions.

The Democratic National Convention kicked off with an inspirational performance by country star Mickey Guyton, who set the tone with her powerful anthem, "All American." This inclusive song celebrates the lights of New York City, the stars in the Texas sky, and the unity found within the pages of a hotel bible. The following days witnessed captivating sets from artists like Jason Isbell, Patti LaBelle, Common, and Lil Jon. Unfortunately, singer-songwriter James Taylor was unable to take the stage due to time constraints. Tonight, Pink is scheduled to energize the crowd before Kamala Harris's highly anticipated speech.

In sharp contrast, the Republican National Convention's musical choices skewed toward older, predominantly white, and male artists. The playlist featured classics from acts such as Grand Funk Railroad, Rick Springfield, and Steely Dan. The inclusion of music by Black artists sparked controversy, with Isaac Hayes' estate currently suing the Trump campaign for unauthorized use of "Hold On, I'm Coming," and Beyoncé threatening legal action over the use of her song "Freedom" in a deleted social media clip. The RNC's musical offerings largely evaded modern pop hits, with One Direction's "What Makes You Beautiful" being the closest to a contemporary choice.

These contrasting musical selections not only highlight the differing tastes of the two parties but also reflect their desired image. The Republican convention aimed to project strength, resilience, and machismo, delving into the comforting tunes of the past to appeal to a nostalgic sentiment. On the other hand, the Democratic convention embraced diversity and inclusivity, curating an eclectic playlist that resonated with women, younger voters, and celebrated the party's historical roots. Both events, however, found common ground in including Tom Petty's resilient anthem, "I Won't Back Down."

As the Democratic National Convention continues, the question of Vice Presidential candidate Kamala Harris's entrance music remains unanswered. Speculation suggests that she may reclaim Beyoncé's empowering anthem, "Freedom." This song not only reflects the power of Black women but also alludes to the Black Lives Matter movement and the struggles America has faced with slavery. Unlike her Republican counterpart, Harris has obtained the artist's permission to use the song, adding a touch of authenticity to her big moment.

The musical choices made by the two national conventions ultimately offer a glimpse into their respective identities and aspirations. While the Republicans harken back to the past with a focus on tradition and toughness, the Democrats strive to build a diverse and inclusive coalition that embraces both the present and the future. The power of music is undeniably central to both parties' strategies, forming a crucial element in their messages to the American people.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related