****

The outcome of the upcoming November election in Arizona could pivot the future of the state's expansive school voucher program, a key issue for Democrats aiming for legislative majority. In a landscape where 40 out of 50 U.S. states experience one-party rule, the bipartisan nature of Arizona's government presents a unique battleground for education policy.

A few years ago, Arizona's Republican-majority legislature transformed a small voucher initiative into one of the nation’s broadest systems. This adjustment allows any family to utilize tax dollars for private school tuition or homeschooling. For Chelsea Ellison, a parent who switched her daughter from public to private schooling, the result has been a game-changer. “It took us a little bit of last year to get her where she should've been in general, and now she's thriving. She loves school,” Ellison reports.

The voucher program's rapid expansion—from serving 12,000 children to over 77,000—illustrates its growing influence. However, parents like Miriam Hoban argue that the approximately $718 million diverted to vouchers last year has severely impacted public schools. Speaking at a Scottsdale Unified school board meeting, Hoban expressed, “I feel like the vouchers definitely take away from the critical dollars that the public schools need to keep providing the excellent schooling that they are capable of providing.”

Arizona's school voucher system serves as a model for advocates of school choice across the country. Nonetheless, critics highlight questionable expenses such as luxury cars, private lessons, and ski resort passes, suggesting misuse and a lack of accountability. Governor Katie Hobbs, who took office in 2023, echoed these concerns, stating that the program’s massive expansion "lacks accountability and will likely bankrupt this state."

As Democrats eye a potential legislative takeover to work in tandem with Governor Hobbs, restrictions on the voucher program appear imminent. Arizona pollster Paul Bentz foresees that while a complete repeal might be unrealistic due to swing districts, Democrats could implement significant regulatory changes. "There would be regulation on it and probably some definite changes to the program," Bentz predicts.

Parents benefiting from the voucher program, like Ellison, support additional safeguards but are wary of any overhaul that could reverse the advancements their children have achieved. "I’ve watched them learn more and want to be part of learning," Ellison notes, adding, "Before, it was fighting to do homework."

As the November election approaches, Arizona stands on the brink of a major decision that could reshape its educational landscape, impacting thousands of students and parents statewide.