Senate Rejects House GOP Proposal, Pursues Different Strategy for Aid to Israel
ICARO Media Group
In a move that further highlights the divide between Democrats and Republicans, the Democrat-controlled Senate announced that it will refuse to consider the House GOP's plan to provide aid to Israel in its fight against Hamas. Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) made the announcement on Thursday, setting the stage for a standoff between the two chambers.
Rather than endorsing the House GOP proposal, Schumer revealed that the Senate will forge ahead by working on its own legislation. This new strategy entails combining Israel assistance with other national security matters, a plan favored by the Biden administration but rejected by House conservatives.
Schumer clarified the Senate's stance, stating, "Let me be clear: The Senate will not take up the House GOP's deeply flawed proposal. Instead, we will work on our own bipartisan emergency aid package that includes funding for aid to Israel, Ukraine, humanitarian aid, including for Gaza, and competition with the Chinese Government."
The House GOP proposal aims to offset $14.3 billion in aid for Israel by cutting the same amount of funds intended for the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). It is expected to be voted on in the House later on Thursday, but it already faces a veto threat from the White House.
While the House Republican plan aligns with the amount of money sought by the Biden administration for Israel aid, Israel aid is just one component of President Joe Biden's approximately $106 billion request for national security-related funds. The request includes $61.4 billion for Ukraine in its fight against Russia, as well as funds for Taiwan, the Indo-Pacific region, humanitarian assistance, and border security.
During a press conference, new House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-LA) emphasized his preference for an Israel assistance package that includes federal spending cuts. Stressing the nation's dire financial situation, Johnson asserted the need to address the $33.7 trillion national debt, stating, "We want to protect and help and assist our friend Israel, but we have to keep our own house in order as well." He also made it clear that the Biden administration and Senate Republicans are aware of their commitment to responsible fiscal policies.
In the Senate, overcoming a filibuster requires a bipartisan 60-vote coalition. Some Republicans expressed concerns about complicating the popular Israel assistance proposal by adding other elements, while others signaled openness to linking aid packages.
Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) stated that any measure combining aid for Israel and Ukraine is "just not going to pass in the House." Meanwhile, Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) argued that these conflicts should be addressed together. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) emphasized the intertwined nature of threats to the United States and called on Washington to rally behind its allies in his remarks on the Senate floor.
Democrats opposing the House GOP proposal have seized on a Congressional Budget Office (CBO) analysis that found the offset idea would decrease revenues by $26.8 billion over 10 years, potentially increasing the federal deficit by $12.5 billion over the same period. Schumer criticized the House GOP's proposal, accusing it of politicizing aid to Israel, inflating the deficit, and failing to address global national security threats.
Johnson dismissed the CBO assessment, telling reporters, "Only in Washington when you cut spending do they call it an increase in the deficit."
The deadlock between the Senate and the House GOP sets the stage for a tense battle over how best to provide aid to Israel amidst ongoing conflicts. As discussions continue, the path forward for emergency aid to Israel and other national security priorities remains uncertain.