Jury Finds Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital Liable in $220 Million 'Take Care of Maya' Case
ICARO Media Group
After eight weeks of intense arguments and testimony, a jury consisting of four women and two men reached a verdict in the highly publicized $220 million case against Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital. The case, which became the premise of the Netflix documentary 'Take Care of Maya,' revolved around the allegations made by the Kowalski family, involving the hospital's actions that they claimed led to the tragic death of family matriarch, Beata Kowalski.
Following the closing arguments presented by both legal teams on Tuesday, the jury deliberated for two days before delivering their verdict. The jury unanimously found Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital liable for all seven claims brought against them by the Kowalski family, including false imprisonment, battery, medical negligence, fraudulent billing, survivor claim for intentional infliction of emotional distress, wrongful death claim for intentional infliction of emotional distress causing death, and Maya Kowalski's claim for infliction of emotional distress.
Maya, Jack, and Kyle Kowalski, visibly emotional, shed tears as the jury read out their decision, which had been years in the making. Now, the jury's next step is to determine the punitive damages that the hospital will be held accountable for. Following the delivery of the verdict, the jury took a brief recess and is expected to reconvene later for this crucial decision.
Throughout the trial, the jurors heard compelling testimonies from the Kowalski family, medical professionals, doctors, nurses, and various experts. They were tasked with evaluating whether the hospital's actions could have prevented the tragedy and if their conduct pushed Beata Kowalski to take her own life. The Kowalski family's claims centered around the allegation that the hospital medically kidnapped Maya and subjected her to abuse during her time in their care.
The case took some unexpected turns during the proceedings. Last week, the defense team was questioned by the Kowalski family's attorneys regarding the hospital's Joint Commission review, as it had received an immediate jeopardy citation during the period when Maya was hospitalized. Additionally, the family's attorneys revealed documents that highlighted a culture of retaliation and retribution within the hospital, leading to the dismissal of several executives and a subsequent re-education campaign.
Maya Kowalski herself took the stand, describing her harrowing experience being held in state custody at the hospital and detailing instances of mistreatment and neglect. Witnesses, including doctors and nurses, testified about Maya's behavior, her mother's alleged attempts to manipulate her treatment, and concerns about potential Munchausen syndrome by proxy. However, the defense experts argued against the validity of Maya's diagnosis and the use of ketamine treatments, emphasizing alternative therapies.
The trial also delved into the hospital's billing practices, with the Kowalski family claiming that while the hospital doubted Maya's diagnosis, they were charging them and their insurance over half a million dollars for her treatment. An economist provided an in-depth analysis, estimating the family's expenses and total damages sought at $220 million.
The verdict and subsequent determination of punitive damages will have significant repercussions for Johns Hopkins All Children's Hospital. The outcome of this landmark case could potentially reshape the standards of medical care and accountability across the healthcare industry.