Federal Judge Blocks California Law Banning Concealed Firearms in Certain Public Places
ICARO Media Group
In a significant legal development, a federal judge has issued a preliminary injunction blocking parts of a California law that would have prohibited carrying concealed firearms in specific "sensitive places." The law, signed by California Governor Gavin Newsom in September as part of a series of gun control measures, targeted places of worship, public libraries, amusement parks, zoos, and sporting events.
US District Judge Cormac Carney, in his ruling, expressed concerns that the provisions outlined in Senate Bill 2 unconstitutionally infringed upon the Second Amendment rights of concealed carry permit holders. He referred to the law's broad coverage, describing it as "sweeping" and "repugnant to the Second Amendment," criticizing its disregard for the Supreme Court.
California Attorney General Rob Bonta announced the state's intention to appeal the decision, arguing that the court got it wrong. Bonta emphasized that Senate Bill 2 adhered to the guidelines set by the Supreme Court and expressed concern about potential risks to public safety if the ruling were to stand.
Governor Newsom promptly denounced the judge's decision, describing it as defying common sense and undermining California's efforts to promote gun safety. He highlighted the need to protect spaces like hospitals, libraries, and children's playgrounds from potential firearms-related threats.
The judge's ruling referred to the recent Supreme Court decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, which established that gun regulations should be evaluated based on their consistency with the nation's historical tradition. Judge Carney found that California had not provided sufficient historical evidence to justify the breadth of the ban in specific public areas.
While the decision blocked the concealed carry ban in the locations challenged in the lawsuits, it left the existing prohibitions on carrying guns in schools, airports, and legislative offices unchanged.
Gun rights groups, such as the California Rifle and Pistol Association and Gun Owners of America, celebrated the judge's decision. Firearms Policy Coalition President Brandon Combs applauded the ruling as a victory for Californians and individual liberties, aligning with the Constitution and previous Supreme Court precedence.
The Supreme Court's ruling in Bruen has influenced several circuit court decisions across the country, resulting in the blockage of various gun laws. These cases encompassed issues such as felons' rights to own guns, possession of firearms without serial numbers, firearms ownership by individuals with restraining orders, and state-level assault weapon bans.
As California prepares to appeal the decision, the court battle over gun control measures and the interpretation of Second Amendment rights is poised to continue.