Ecologist Urges a Halt to Mass Tree Planting, Highlighting Drawbacks and Greenwashing

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/15940837/original/open-uri20231216-56-gc16w0?1702752883
ICARO Media Group
News
16/12/2023 18h52

In a surprising turn of events, renowned ecologist Thomas Crowther, the former chief scientific adviser for the United Nation's Trillion Trees Campaign, has called for a halt to mass tree planting initiatives. Speaking at this year's UN Climate Change Conference in Dubai, Crowther pointed out the overlooked drawbacks of these endeavors and their role in greenwashing, as reported by Wired.

Crowther cautioned against the assumption that tree planting is an effective solution for carbon capture, stifling biodiversity, and diverting attention from the pressing need to cut emissions. He emphasized that the call to plant a trillion trees has ultimately obscured the critical focus on reducing greenhouse gas emissions. "If no one had ever said, 'Plant a trillion trees,' I think we'd have been in a lot better space," Crowther stated. He added that the overwhelming attention on tree planting has allowed responsible scientists to address and rectify the misconceptions surrounding it.

However, it was Crowther's groundbreaking study published in 2019 that initially sparked the global tree-planting craze. The study boldly claimed that the planet could accommodate an additional 1.2 trillion trees, labeling global tree restoration as the most effective climate change solution to date. Despite skepticism from some scientists, the study's optimism gained momentum.

Major players, including big oil companies like Shell, seized the opportunity and pledged substantial investments in reforestation projects. The viral social media campaign, Team Trees, aimed to plant 20 million saplings and even received a generous million-dollar donation from Tesla CEO Elon Musk.

Despite the enthusiasm and widespread attention, carbon emissions have continued to rise. Crowther's recent study, published in the journal Nature, confronts the practice of greenwashing, where entities boast about eco-friendly efforts to overshadow their detrimental environmental practices. By speaking at the climate summit, he aimed to bring an end to this deceitful practice.

According to Crowther, the focus should shift towards preserving existing forests rather than planting new ones. His research indicates that natural expansion and maturation of existing woodlands will ultimately offset roughly 50 percent more carbon in the long run. The redistribution of wealth to Indigenous populations, farmers, and local communities who live with biodiversity is also necessary for sustainable conservation efforts.

While the efficacy of carbon offsetting in the fight against climate change remains contentious, the destruction of precious forests undoubtedly exacerbates the crisis. Crowther's plea for a halt to mass tree planting serves as a reminder to reevaluate our environmental strategies and prioritize sustainable practices that benefit both nature and humanity.

In related news, scientists have discovered that carbon dioxide is becoming increasingly formidable. Ongoing research sheds light on the escalating impact of this greenhouse gas, further emphasizing the urgency to address climate change.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related