US Supreme Court to Review Nvidia Case Involving Crypto Mining Revenue, Potentially Impacting Shareholder Lawsuits
ICARO Media Group
The US Supreme Court has decided to review a case involving tech company Nvidia Corp.'s crypto mining revenue, a move that could have significant implications for shareholder lawsuits. The case centers around an investor suit claiming that Nvidia was "deceptive" about its reliance on crypto mining revenue prior to a 2018 market downturn.
Nvidia is seeking to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing that it lacks sufficient specificity. The ruling by the Supreme Court will determine whether the lawsuit can proceed or be dismissed. If the decision favors Nvidia, it could give companies greater leverage to dismiss shareholder suits early on, potentially avoiding costly litigation.
Shareholders in the case allege that Nvidia's CEO, Jensen Huang, concealed the fact that the record revenue growth in 2017 and 2018 was primarily driven by crypto mining-related sales of the flagship GeForce GPU product, rather than gaming sales. They claim that the volatility of the crypto market exposed Nvidia to more risk than disclosed.
In November 2018, Nvidia announced a revenue shortfall, causing a significant decline of over 28% in its stock over two days. Huang attributed the decline to a "crypto hangover." Shareholders argue that this downturn revealed a discrepancy between Nvidia's prior statements, which downplayed the significance of mining-related demand, and the actual situation.
Investors further contend that internal communications involving Nvidia's CEO could reveal the true extent of GPU sales to cryptocurrency miners. However, Nvidia asserts that no evidence supporting these claims has been presented.
The 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco previously ruled that the shareholders' lawsuit could proceed, disagreeing with Nvidia's argument for dismissal. However, Nvidia has appealed this decision, highlighting the absence of internal company documents supporting the allegations of misleading statements.
If the Supreme Court sides with Nvidia and establishes a higher bar for shareholder lawsuits, it could make it easier for companies to secure early dismissals of such cases. This outcome has the potential to reshape the dynamics of shareholder litigation, affecting the level of accountability demanded from companies regarding their public statements and disclosures.
Meanwhile, the total valuation of the crypto market currently stands at $2.3 trillion, experiencing a decline from its mid-March peak of $2.7 trillion. Major cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin (BTC), have been trading within a range of $56,000 to $71,000 over the past two months. Bitcoin is currently valued at $65,000, following an unsuccessful attempt to retest its all-time high of $73,700.
The Supreme Court's decision in the Nvidia case will likely have far-reaching implications for the future of shareholder lawsuits and could potentially influence the level of accountability required from companies in the crypto industry.