Texas Court Blocks Attorney General's Demand for Private Information from LGBTQ Nonprofit PFLAG
ICARO Media Group
In a recent development, the Texas Office of the Attorney General has been barred from obtaining sensitive information and documents from PFLAG, a national nonprofit organization that provides support to families of LGBTQ individuals, including transgender youths seeking gender-affirming care. The temporary injunction was issued on Monday by Travis County District Court Judge Amy Clark Meachum, who expressed concerns about potential harm to PFLAG and its members if they were forced to disclose information such as the identities of individuals seeking gender-affirming care for minors.
The court ruling has been hailed as a victory for PFLAG and the LGBTQ community in Texas. Brian K. Bond, CEO of PFLAG, stated that "PFLAG families in Texas gained further protection today when the court reaffirmed that the Attorney General can't two-step around the law with an outrageous demand for private information." The Texas Office of the Attorney General did not provide an immediate comment regarding the court's decision.
PFLAG received civil demands on February 9 from the Attorney General's office, requesting the turnover of communications, documents, and other relevant information pertaining to its work in supporting families with transgender children. These demands were made as part of an effort to investigate medical providers offering gender-affirming care to minors, despite the state's Senate Bill 14, which banned such treatments.
In response to the investigation demands, PFLAG filed a lawsuit on February 28, seeking a temporary restraining order and relief to safeguard its members' privacy. The Attorney General's office, in turn, vowed to hold PFLAG accountable, arguing that the organization's information was vital to their investigations into potential insurance fraud committed by medical providers circumventing Senate Bill 14.
On March 1, PFLAG obtained a temporary restraining order with the assistance of Lambda Legal, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), and the Transgender Law Center. This restraining order remained in effect until the recent hearing on March 25, when Judge Amy Clark Meachum issued the injunction, stating that there is a significant likelihood that PFLAG will succeed at trial. The trial itself is scheduled to commence on June 10.
Chloe Kempf, an attorney from the ACLU of Texas, hailed the court ruling as a critical step in allowing PFLAG and its members to advocate freely without fear of retaliation or intimidation from the Attorney General. This legal victory for PFLAG comes amidst broader efforts in Texas to restrict access to transition-related care for minors. In September, the Texas Supreme Court allowed a new state law banning gender-affirming care for minors to take effect. In December, the Attorney General asked a Seattle hospital to release records relating to gender-affirming treatment potentially provided to children from Texas.
The outcome of this ongoing legal battle remains to be seen, but the court's decision to block the Attorney General's demand for private information represents a significant victory for PFLAG and the protection of privacy rights for LGBTQ families in Texas.