### Critics Proven Wrong as Portland’s Tree-Lighting Ceremony Shines Brightly

After enduring a week of harsh criticism, Portland's holiday tree ultimately delighted spectators during the annual tree-lighting ceremony on Friday. Held in Monument Square, the event attracted hundreds of attendees who cheered as the lights were turned on at precisely 4:30 p.m., transforming the previously derided tree into a seasonal spectacle.

Controversy surrounded this year’s tree selection, with many residents describing it as scragglier and thinner than trees from prior years. Some even commented that the tree looked "Charlie Brown-y" or "like a joke." Despite these concerns, the holiday spirit prevailed as the crowd responded enthusiastically once the lights illuminated the Portland-grown tree.

One of the event’s perennial attendees, Julie Lankford, admitted she was initially skeptical. "It was 50/50. I wasn't quite sure," the Portland resident of over 20 years said. "It definitely looks better with the lights."

City officials explained that this year's tree was chosen due to particular constraints. It grew in a confined space between two residential buildings in Portland’s Deering neighborhood and was slated for removal regardless. Jessica Grondin, a city spokesperson, noted that dry conditions limited the available selection of trees. As a result, the chosen tree represented a more sustainable and locally accessible option.

Portland arborist Mark Reiland emphasized that aesthetics were only one consideration. "We're really trying to build up the green infrastructure and build upon it in the city," Reiland stated, adding that the tree’s modest height and sparse branches allowed for a distinctive lighting strategy that included illuminating the trunk.

Attendees like Chris Clegg and Erika Petri were optimistic. "I think every tree deserves a chance," Petri said, expressing happiness that the tree was set for removal anyway, which to her, justified its selection for the city’s holiday display. Portland Mayor Mark Dion echoed a sentiment of growing appreciation for the tree, remarking, "The longer I look at it, the more it grows on me."

From a public perspective, Leana Good-Simpson captured the sentiments of many when she photographed the newly lit tree. "I think with the lesser leaves it just looks beautiful," she commented, appreciating the simplicity and elegance that others had initially missed.

Despite its pre-lighting criticism, the Portland tree lighting event proved to be a heartwarming display, showcasing the enduring holiday spirit of the community.