Manasquan High School Denied Final Appeal, Championship Game Proceeds as Planned
ICARO Media Group
In a disappointing turn of events for the boys' basketball team at Manasquan High School, their last-ditch efforts to challenge the outcome of a crucial game have been denied by the New Jersey State Superior Court's Appellate Division. This latest appeal denial effectively puts an end to the legal battle for Manasquan, as school district officials announced they would not pursue further litigation, including an appeal to the New Jersey Supreme Court.
The decision from the Appellate Division comes after Manasquan's attorney, Gerald Clark, confirmed that there would be no additional legal action involving the case, as reported by NJ.com. With this denial, the school district's appeal has now been rejected by the New Jersey State Interscholastic Athletic Association, the court system, the Department of Education, and the Appellate Division.
The controversy began when referees overturned their initial ruling on Griffin Linstra's buzzer-beater shot during a game against Camden. The reversal ultimately impacted the game's outcome, leading to a tight legal battle between Manasquan officials and the referee's decision. While video evidence clearly showed that Linstra's shot was released before the clock expired, the legal avenues sought by Manasquan failed to change the final result.
Notably, the Appellate Division justified their decision to deny Manasquan's application for an emergent appeal by highlighting the potential negative implications of allowing game officials' calls to be continuously challenged. They stressed that ongoing litigation, appeals, and scheduling issues would arise if every disputed call ended up in court. The Division acknowledged Manasquan's disappointment but remained constrained in their ruling.
Further setbacks for Manasquan occurred when Judge Mark Troncone denied their request to postpone the scheduled Group 2 championship game on Saturday. The New Jersey Department of Education also upheld the referee's ruling, stating that the result was not subject to review.
With the legal battle now settled, Camden is set to play against Arts High School of Newark in the Group 2 championship game, which will take place at noon on Saturday at the Rutgers campus. Despite Manasquan's best efforts, they will not have the opportunity to compete for the championship title based on the outcome of their disputed game against Camden.
Although disappointed, the Manasquan community must now shift their focus from legal action to supporting their fellow athletes and preparing for the future. Nonetheless, the controversy surrounding the overturned call and subsequent legal proceedings will likely serve as a reminder of the challenges faced in the world of high school sports and the subjective nature of officiating decisions.