Lawsuit Filed by Manasquan Seeks to Overturn Controversial Semifinal Outcome

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/16095341/original/open-uri20240307-17-2tid31?1709842475
ICARO Media Group
Politics
07/03/2024 20h12

In a stunning turn of events, Manasquan High School has filed a lawsuit in an attempt to overturn the outcome of its Group 2 semifinal game against Camden and secure a chance to play for the state title this weekend. The lawsuit, filed with the New Jersey Superior Court's Chancery Division in Ocean County, seeks "injunctive relief" to put the championship game on hold until a court can resolve the matter.

According to documents provided by the Clark Law Firm, representing the Manasquan Board of Education, the lawsuit argues that the NJSIAA (New Jersey State Interscholastic Athletic Association) should rectify the situation and adhere to its own rules. Attorney Gerald Clark, Principal of the Clark Law Firm, expects Judge Troncone to set a hearing sometime today.

The controversy revolves around a buzzer-beating put-back by Manasquan's Griffin Linstra during the semifinal game. Video footage from Overtime's X account clearly shows that the shot was released before the clock expired. Initially, one of the officials signaled that the basket counted, and the scoreboard reflected a 47-46 victory for Manasquan. However, a discussion among the officials took place following the intervention of Camden coaches, which, according to a veteran official, should not have occurred.

In the aftermath, Manasquan coach Andrew Bilodeau expressed his shock and frustration, claiming that his team had outplayed Camden. Manasquan's appeal to the NJSIAA was denied, citing the association's bylaws that deem the final score official once the referees leave the court.

The Clark Law Firm's filing includes first-hand accounts and video evidence showing the officials' huddle and subsequent reversal of the call. Manasquan is now seeking a judicial review, arguing that the NJSIAA should use the video footage to determine the rightful winner and declare Manasquan as such.

Manasquan's hopes now lie with the court hearings and their plea to delay the upcoming championship game scheduled against Arts High School. It remains to be seen how the New Jersey Superior Court will rule on this matter and if Manasquan will have the opportunity to compete for the state title.

As the legal battle unfolds, it is evident that both teams, coaches, players, and fans played no part in the incorrect call made by the officials. Attorney Gerald Clark emphasizes that the NJSIAA has the authority to rectify the situation and should follow its own rules to declare Manasquan the rightful winner.

The outcome of the lawsuit will not only impact the immediate fate of both teams but also raise questions about the integrity of the officiating process in high school sports. As this case garners attention, the entire state eagerly awaits the decision of Judge Troncone and whether Manasquan will be granted the opportunity to compete in the championship game against Arts High School.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related